| 1969 | 1970 | 1971 | 1972 |
| Lee Green, CF | Scott Northey, CF | John Matias, CF | Keith Marshall, CF |
| Luis Alcarez, 3B | Lee Green, LF | Bobby Floyd, 2B | Jim Wohlford, 2B |
| Dennis Paepke, 1B | Fran Healy, C | Billy Sorrell, RF | Carl Taylor, RF |
| Dave Nicholson, LF | Billy Sorrell, 3B | Chuck Harrison, 1B | Gary Sanserino, LF |
| Paul Schaal, SS | Chuck Harrison, 1B | Tom Matchick, SS | Buck Martinez, C |
| Fred Rico, RF | Fred Rico, RF | Jay Ward, 3B | Dan Haynes, 1B |
| Larry Osborne, DH | Juan Rios, SS | Ken Huebner, LF | Jose Martinez, 3B |
| Fran Healy, C | Steve McMillian, 2B | John Sullivan, C | Rich Severson, SS |
| Rich Severson, 2B | Chris Zachary, P | Monty Montgomery, P | Mike Jackson, P |
| Chris Zachary, P | | | |
| | | | |
| 1973 | 1974 | 1975 | 1976 |
| Frank White, 2B | Keith Marshall, LF | U.L. Washington, SS | U.L. Washington, SS |
| Jose Arcia, SS | Rocky Craig, CF | Mark Williams, CF | Sheldon Mallory, RF |
| Tom Poquette, RF | Tom Poquette, RF | Jamie Quirk, 3B | Ruppert Jones, CF |
| Jim Wohlford, DH | Frank Ortenzio, 1B | Frank Ortenzio, 1B | Frank Ortenzio, 1B |
| Gary Sanserino, 1B | George Brett, 3B | Gary Martz, DH | Gary Martz, LF |
| Jim Clark, LF | Jim Clark, DH | Ruppert Johnes, RF | John Wathan, C |
| George Brett, 3B | Dennis Paepke, C | Craig Perkins, C | Bill Sudakis, 3B |
| Buck Martinez, C | Harold Hunter, 2B | Steve Staggs, 2B | Steve Staggs, 2B |
| Monty Montgomery, P | Jose Arcia, SS | Keith Marshall, LF | Tom Bruno, P |
| | Dennis Leonard, P | Dennis Leonard, P | |
| | | | |
| 1977 | 1978 | 1979 | 1980 |
| U.L. Washington, SS | German Barranca, 2B | Tim Ireland, 2B | German Barranca, LF |
| Dave Cripe, 3B | Darrel Parker, LF | Dave Cripe, 3B | Manny Castillo, 2B |
| Joe Lahoud, LF | Dave Cripe, 3B | Jim Nettles, LF | Ken Phelps, 1B |
| Gary Martz, 1B | Randy Bass, 1B | Kevin Gillen, RF | Luis Silverio, DH |
| Clint Hurdle, RF | Craig Perkins, DH | Darrel Parker, DH | Leon Brown, CF |
| Willie Wilson, CF | Jim Nettles, RF | Todd Cruz, SS | Dave Augustine, RF |
| Steve Patchin, C | Luis Silverio, CF | Ken Phelps, 3B | Keith Drumright, 2B |
| Rudy Kinard, 2B | Jim Gaudet, C | Jim Gaudet, C | Kelly Heath, SS |
| Dave Hasbach, P | Mike Denevi, SS | Bob Detherage, CF | Dave Hogg, C |
| | Rich Gale, P | Bill Paschall, P | Ken Cvejdik, P |
| | | | |
| 1981 | 1982 | 1983 | 1984 |
| Dan Garcia, RF | Pat Sheridan, CF | Pat Sheridan, CF | Rondin Johnson, 2B |
| Kelly Heath, 2B | Mark Ryal, RF | Buddy Biancalana, SS | Steve Hammond, DH |
| Manny Castillo, 3B | Don Slaught, C | Mark Ryal, LF | John Morris, CF |
| Bombo Rivera, DH | Darryl Motley, LF | Bombo Rivera, DH | Mike Brewer, RF |
| Onix Concepcion, SS | Bombo Rivera, DH | Mark Funderburk, 1B | Dave Leeper, LF |
| Ron Johnson, 1B | Dave Edler, 3B | Mike Brewer, RF | Mark Ryal, 1B |
| Darryl Motley, LF | Ron Johnson, 1B | Cliff Pastornicky, 2B | Cliff Pastornicky, 3B |
| Pat Sheridan, CF | Brad Wellman, 2B | Russ Stephans, C | Russ Stephans, C |
| Greg Keatley, C | Buddy Biancalana, SS | Kelly Heath, 2B | Jim Scranton, SS |
| Dan Fischer, P | Keith Creel, P | Derek Botelho, P | Charlie Leibrandt, P |
| | | | |
| 1985 | 1986 | 1987 | 1988 |
| Rondin Johnson, 2B | Dwight Taylor, CF | Rondin Johnson, 2B | Gary Thurman, LF |
| John Morris, CF | Bill Pecota, 3B | Bill Pecota, SS | Rondin Johnson, 2B |
| Butch Davis, DH | Mike Kingery, LF | Chito Martinez, LF | Luis de los Santos, DH |
| Dave Leeper, LF | Mike Brewer, RF | Scotti Madison, 1B | Joe Citari, 1B |
| Pat Putnam, 1B | Jeff Schulz, DH | Jeff Schulz, DH | Nick Capra, RF |
| Mike Kingery, RF | Joe Citari, 1B | Van Snider, RF | Joe Castro, 3B |
| Bill Pecota, 3B | Bill Hayes, C | Luis de los Santos, 3B | Dave Owen, SS |
| Brian Poldberg, C | Mike Miller, 2B | Mike Macfarlane, C | Larry Owen, C |
| Jim Scranton, SS | Jim Scranton, SS | Gary Thurman, CF | Mike Loggins, CF |
| Mike Griffin, P | Scott Bankhead, P | Bill Swaggerty, P | Rich Anderson, P |
| | | | |
| 1989 | 1990 | 1991 | 1992 |
| Nick Capra, LF | Terry Shumpert, 2B | Bobby Moore, CF | Kevin Long, RF |
| Mike Mesh, SS | Thad Reece, 3B | Paul Zuvella, SS | Jose Mota, 2B |
| Luis de los Santos, 1B | Chito Martinrz, RF | Sean Berry, 3B | Harvey Pulliam, LF |
| Nick Castaneda, DH | Bob Hamelin, 1B | Bob Hamelin, DH | Luis Medina, DH |
| Jeff Schulz, RF | Russ Morman, DH | Jeff Conine, 1B | Jeff Conine, 1B |
| Ed Hearn, C | Harvey Pulliam, LF | Harvey Pulliam, LF | Sean Berry, 3B |
| Jose Castro, 3B | Tim Spehr, C | Jacob Brumfield, RF | Tim Spehr, C |
| Mike Loggins, CF | Bobby Meachem, SS | Frank Laureano, 2B | Kevin Koslofski, CF |
| Terry Shumpert, 2B | Mike Loggins, CF | Tim Spehr, C | Rico Rossy, SS |
| Kevin Appier, P | Pete Filson, P | Mike Magnante, P | Mark Huismann, P |
| | | | |
| 1993 | 1994 | 1995 | 1996 |
| Kevin Long, LF | Jose Mota, 2B | J.T. Bruett, CF | Felix Martinez, SS |
| Mike Kingery, RF | Rico Rossy, SS | Steve Sisco, 2B | Roderick Myers, CF |
| Dan Rohrmeier, DH | Russ McGinnis, C | Michael Tucker, LF | Chris Stynes, LF |
| Bob Hamelin, 2B | Glenn Davis, DH | Jeff Grotewold, 1B | Jeff Grotewold, 1B |
| Russ McGinnis, 3B | Michael Tucker, LF | Keith Hughes, RF | Kevin Young, 3B |
| Kevin Koslofski, CF | Joe Vitello, 1B | Keith Miller, DH | Scooter Tucker, C |
| Nelson Santovenia, C | Phil Hiatt, RF | Henry Mercedes, C | Andy Stewart, DH |
| Terry Shumpert, 2B | Joe Randa, 3B | Gary Green, SS | Ramon Martinez, 2B |
| David Howard, SS | Les Norman, CF | Keith Lockhart, 3B | Darren Burton, RF |
| Chris Haney, P | Paul Abbott, P | Dennis Rasmussen, P | Mel Bunch |
| | | | |
| 1997 | 1998 | 1999 | 2000 |
| Felix Martinez, SS | Terry Bradshaw, CF | Ray Holbert, SS | Goefrey Tomlinson, CF |
| Chris Stynes, DH | Scott Luius, DH | Les Norman, RF | Anthony Medrano, SS |
| Jon Nunnally, CF | Jeremy Giambi, LF | Mark Quinn, LF | Dee Brown, LF |
| Yamil Benitez, LF | Chris Hatcher, RF | Joe Vitiello, 1B | Kit Pellow, 1B |
| Larry Sutton, 1B | Luis Ortiz, 3B | Sal Fasano, C | Kevin Orie, 3B |
| Ryan Long, RF | Carlos Mendez, 1B | Carlos Mendez, DH | Jorge Fabregas, C |
| Sal Fasano, C | Orlando Miller, 2B | Steve Gibralter, CF | Les Norman, RF |
| Mendy Lopez, 3B | Joe Kmak, C | Kit Pelow, 3B | Emiliano Escandon, DH |
| Jed Hansen, 2B | Mendy Lopez, SS | Jed Hansen, 2B | Alejandro Prieto, 2B |
| Jim Pittsley, P | Brian Barber, P | Dan Reischert, P | Brett Laxton, P |
| | | | |
| 2001 | 2002 | 2003 | 2004 |
| Jeff Berblinger, DH | Donzell McDonald, CF | Luis Ordaz, SS | David DeJesus, CF |
| Craig Wilson, 3B | Angel Berroa, SS | Julius Matos, 2B | Wilton Guerrero, 2B |
| Jon Nunnally, LF | Aaron Guiel, RF | Aaron Guiel, RF | Jarrod Patterson, DH |
| Kit Pellow, 1B | Kit Pellow, 3B | Morgan Burkhart, 1B | Rick Short, 3B |
| Trenidad Hubbard, CF | Dee Brown, LF | Jarrod Patterson, 3B | Calvin Pickering, 1B |
| Aaron Guiel, RF | Ken Harvey, 1B | Benny Agbayani, DH | Byron Gettis, LF |
| Melvin Rosario, C | Jon Nunnally, DH | Alexis Gomez, CF | Alexis Gomez, RF |
| Wilson Delgado, 2B | Danny Ardoin, C | Mike Kelly, LF | Alberto Castillo, C |
| Nick Ortiz, SS | Joe Espada, 2B | Fernando Lunar, C | Gookie Dawkins, SS |
| Chad Durbin, P | Chris George, P | Shawn Sedlacek, P | Brad Voyles, P |
| | | | |
| 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 |
| Adrian Brown, CF | Kerry Robinson, CF | Joey Gathright, CF | Mitch Maier, CF |
| Joe McEwing, 3B | Ruben Gotay, 2B | Angel Berroa, SS | Mike Aviles, 2B |
| Aaron Guiel, RF | Aaron Guiel, RF | Billy Butler, LF | Shane Costa, RF |
| Ken Harvey, 1B | Chad Allen, DH | Shane Costa, RF | Ryan Shealy, 1B |
| Matt Diaz, LF | Chip Ambres, LF | Justin Huber, 1B | Damon Hollins, DH |
| Paul Phillips, C | Paul Phillips, C | Mitch Maier, RF | Jason Smith, 3B |
| Luis Ugueto, 2B | Justin Huber, 1B | Mike Aviles, 3B | Angel Berroa, SS |
| Chad Santos, DH | Mike Aviles, 3B | Paul Phillips, C | Chris Lubanski, LF |
| Andres Blanco, SS | Andres Blanco, SS | Andres Blanco, 2B | Ken Huckaby, C |
| Jimmy Gobble, P | Bobby Keppel, P | Brian Bannister, P | Luke Hochevar, P |
| | | | |
| 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 |
| Mitch Maier, CF | Irving Falu, SS | Lance Zawadski, SS | Jarrod Dyson, CF |
| Tommy Murphy, 3B | Marc Maddox, 2B | David Lough, RF | Derrick Robinson, LF |
| Shane Costa, RF | Wilson Betimit, 3B | Eric Hosmer, 1B | Johnny Giavotella, 2B |
| Kila Ka'aihue, 1B | Kila Ka'aihue, 1B | Mike Moustakas, 3B | Clint Robinson, 1B |
| Ryan Shealy, DH | David Lough, CF | Johnny Giavotella, 2B | Kevin Kouzmanoff, 3B |
| Chris Lubanski, LF | Jordan Parraz, RF | Clint Robinson, DH | David Lough, RF |
| J.R. House, C | Scott Thorman, DH | Gregor Blanco, LF | Max Ramirez, DH |
| Tug Hulett, 2B | Buck Coats, LF | Manny Pina, C | Tony Abreu, SS |
| Luis Hernandez, SS | Edwin Bellorin, C | Paulo Orlando, CF | Cody Clark, C |
| Brian Bannister, P | Gaby Hernandez, P | Mike Montgomery, P | Will Smith, P |
| | | | |
| 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | 2016 |
| David Lough, LF | Brett Eibner, CF | Whit Merrifield, LF | Whit Merrifield, 2B |
| Christian Colon, SS | Christian Colon, 2B | Rey Fuentes, CF | Brett Eibner, CF |
| Johnny Giavotella, 2B | Johnny Giavotella, 3B | Brett Eibner, CF | Cheslor Cuthbert, 3B |
| Max Ramirez, DH | Jimmy Paredes, RF | Moises Sierra, DH | Jose Martinez, LF |
| Xavier Nady, 1B | Brian Fletcher, DH | Cheslor Cuthbert, 3B | Balbino Fuenmayor, 1B |
| Adam Moore, C | Matt Fields, 1B | Matt Fields, 1B | Jorge Bonifacio, RF |
| Irving Falu, 3B | Jason Donald, SS | Orlando Calixte, SS | Travis Snider, DH |
| Willy Taveras, RF | Francisco Pena, C | Francisco Pena, C | Tony Cruz, C |
| Paulo Orlando, CF | Paulo Orlando, LF | Ryan Jackson, 2B | Clint Barmes, SS |
| Will Smith, P | Chris Dwyer, P | Aaron Brooks, P | Miguel Almonte, P |
| | | | |
| 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | |
| Billy Burns, LF | Ramon Torres, SS | Erick Mejia, CF | |
| Ramon Torres, SS | Billy Burns, CF | Nicky Lopez, SS | |
| Whit Merrifield, 3B | Hunter Dozier, 3B | Jorge Bonifacio, LF | |
| Peter O'Brien, DH | Ryan O'Hearn, 1B | Cheslor Cuthbert | |
| Jorge Bonifacio, RF | Frank Schwindel, DH | Kelvin Gutierrez, 3B | |
| Ryan O'Hearn, 1B | Tyler Collins, RF | Humberto Arteaga, 2B | |
| Bubba Starling, CF | Logan Moon, LF | Elier Hernandez, DH | |
| Cam Gallagher, C | Humberto Arteaga, 2B | Brett Phillips, RF | |
| Corey Toups, 2B | Nick Dini, C | Nick Dini, C | |
| Jonathan Dziedzic, P | Jonathan Dziedzic | Heath Fillmyer, P | |
