Check Swing Challenge system being tested in Arizona Fall League
It’s one of the great sports debates – was that a swing? Every baseball fan has participated in the discourse at one point or another. You’re watching a game when a pitcher throws, say, a nasty changeup that dives below the zone. Fooled only briefly, the hitter begins to swing
It’s one of the great sports debates – was that a swing?
Every baseball fan has participated in the discourse at one point or another. You’re watching a game when a pitcher throws, say, a nasty changeup that dives below the zone. Fooled only briefly, the hitter begins to swing but checks himself just in time. Or did he? The home-plate umpire can’t tell, calls a ball and the catcher points to the first-base or third-base umpire for appeal. Then fans see multiple camera angles and slow-motion video that the umpire doesn’t, and the debate rages.
Let’s face it, the check-swing call is one of the most subjective in baseball. Major League Baseball is now beginning preliminary testing of technology to gauge whether there is a way to create more clarity on check swings.
Using the same Hawk-Eye technology as the Automated Ball-Strike Challenge system already in place in the Arizona Fall League, the Check Swing Challenge is being used on a limited basis in a proof-of-concept stage at Salt River Field.
Teams will be able to challenge an on-field check-swing call to see if the swing crossed a 45-degree threshold from home plate.
That’s the elevator pitch. Here are more details on the latest review system coming to games at Salt River and why it’s being tested in the weeks ahead.
What is a check swing?
There is no definition for “check swing” in the Official Baseball Rules. The closest thing comes in the Definition of Terms where the first example of a strike is a pitch that “is struck at by the batter.” It’s up to the umpire to decide what “struck at” means. Rule 8.02(c) gets into how managers and catchers can ask for umpire help on “half swing” calls but does not expand from there.
Without official definitions, we’re left in a gray area. Common understanding is that the batter has to “cross the plane” or “break his wrists” in a check swing for it to be a strike, but that’s still at the umpire’s discretion without an official rule to fall back on.
So how would this change?
Under the Check Swing Challenge system, managers and catchers still ask for appeals, and umpires still make an initial call on the field. If players disagree, they can challenge the check-swing call to Hawk-Eye, bringing a replay to the in-stadium video board.
The check swing is called an official swing (and therefore a strike) if the review reveals that the bat exceeds a 45-degree threshold from home plate. Want an easier way to visualize that? The foul line is a 45-degree angle from home. If a right-handed batter swings beyond the first-base line, it’s a strike. If a left-handed batter swings beyond the third-base line, it’s a strike.
📩 CLICK HERE TO SUBSCRIBE TO BEN'S BIZ
How many challenges per team per game?
Each team gets to challenge two check-swing calls per game. If a team uses up those two challenges by the ninth inning, it is granted one additional challenge for the final frame.
Who can challenge?
This is the same as with an ABS Challenge. Only pitchers, hitters and catchers can ask for an official review.
Where will this be first tested?
The Check Swing Challenge will only be used in games played at Salt River Fields at Talking Stick in this year’s Arizona Fall League for now. Salt River serves as the Spring Training home of the D-backs and Rockies. This fall's Salt River Rafters roster is made up of players from those two systems as well as from the Nationals, Twins and Yankees.
Does the Arizona Fall League have a history of testing out potential new rules?
Yes! ABS, pitch clocks, bigger bases, mound visit limits, shift bans – many potential rule changes (both big and small) have been tested in the AFL before they’ve made (or, in some cases, not made) the Majors.
Sam Dykstra is a reporter for MiLB.com. Follow and interact with him on Twitter, @SamDykstraMiLB.
USA Baseball & Durham Bulls Set to Host All-American Women's Baseball Classic
USA Baseball and the Durham Bulls are set to host the All-American Women’s Baseball Classic from August 1-3 at the Durham Bulls Athletic Park (DBAP) in Durham, North Carolina, in conjunction with the All-American Girls Professional Baseball League (AAGPBL) and American Girls Baseball (AGB). The Classic will be an identification
Bulls Bash Knights 3-1 For Fourth Straight Win
Bob Seymour homered twice while Ian Seymour threw 6 1/3 innings to lead the Durham Bulls past the Charlotte Knights 3-1 before a paid attendance of 8,945 at the DBAP on Saturday night. Ian Seymour (W, 6-3) was making his first appearance with Durham (39-29) after his major league debut
Durham Walks Off Charlotte For 2nd Straight Night With 6-5 Win
Tanner Murray singled home Chandler Simpson in the last of the ninth to lift the Durham Bulls past the Charlotte Knights 6-5 at the DBAP on Friday night. The Bulls (38-29) beat the Knights (32-35) for the second straight game in the bottom of the ninth after Andrew Stevenson beat
Bulls Walk-Off With 2-1 Win Over Charlotte
On the 10th pitch of his at-bat, Andrew Stevenson doubled home the tying and winning runs in the bottom of the night to lift the Durham Bulls past the Charlotte Knights 2-1 on Thursday night at the DBAP. The Bulls (37-29) put the first two batters on in the final
Knights Top Bulls 7-6
Former Durham Bull Tristan Gray homered to tie the game in the seventh, then hit a sacrifice fly in the ninth to lift the Charlotte Knights past the Durham Bulls 7-6 at the DBAP on Tuesday night. Gray, who hit 71 homers across 2 1/2 seasons with Durham (35-29), evened
Joe Boyle Earns Third League Pitcher of the Week Honor
Minor League Baseball on Monday afternoon announced that Bulls right-hander Joe Boyle has been named the International League's Pitcher of the Week for the period of June 3-8. It marks the third time Boyle has received a weekly league honor this season. The 25-year-old fired six scoreless innings on June
Williams, Simpson Lead Bulls To 10-2 Win Over 'Shrimp
Behind career days by Carson Williams and Chandler Simpson, the Durham Bulls bombed the Jacksonville Jumbo Shrimp 10-2 in the road trip finale Sunday afternoon at VyStar Ballpark. Williams homered twice and drove in a career-high seven runs, while Simpson had a career-best five hits, going 5-for-5 as the Bulls
Jumbo Shrimp Top Bulls 3-2
Troy Johnston hit a three-run homer in the bottom of the eighth to lift the Jacksonville Jumbo Shrimp past the Durham Bulls 3-2 on Saturday night at VyStar Ballpark. The Bulls (34-28) took a 2-0 lead in the sixth thanks to a double by Kim Ha-Seong and a run-scoring single
7-Run 6th Propels Bulls To 7-1 Win
The Durham Bulls scored all seven of their runs in the sixth inning to defeat the Jacksonville Jumbo Shrimp 7-1 on Friday night at VyStar Ballpark. The Bulls (34-27) sent 11 batters to the plate to break open a 0-0 game. Tristan Peters doubled to lead off the inning, then
Jumbo Shrimp Best Bulls 6-2
Brian Navarreto hit a two-run homer in the sixth inning to lead Jacksonville past Durham 6-2 on Thursday night at VyStar Ballpark. The game started 47 minutes late due to a threat of rain, but when it began, both starters took over. Joe Rock threw five-plus innings, permitting just one
Jacksonville Downs Durham 7-4
Maximo Acosta had three hits and drove in a pair to send the Jacksonville Jumbo Shrimp past the Durham Bulls 7-4 at VyStar Ballpark on Wednesday night. It took eight tries, but the Jumbo Shrimp (35-24) finally defeated the Bulls (33-26). Logan Workman (L, 3-3) surrendered three runs in the
Peters Continues Hot Stretch as Bulls Batter Jumbo Shrimp 7-1
Tristan Peters drove in four runs for the second straight game while Ian Seymour threw six sparkling innings to lead the Durham Bulls past the Jacksonville Jumbo Shrimp 7-1 at VyStar Ballpark on Tuesday night. The Bulls (33-25) remained unbeaten against the Jumbo Shrimp (34-24), winning for the seventh straight
Peters Blasts Bulls Past Redbirds 10-5
Tristan Peters had a career-high four extra base hit game to lead the Durham Bulls past the Memphis Redbirds in the series finale 10-5 at the DBAP on Sunday. Peters homered twice, doubled twice and drove in four runs for the Bulls (32-25), who salvaged their second game in the
Bulls' Late Comeback Efforts Falls Short in 9-8 Defeat
A feverish late-game rally by the Durham Bulls fell one run short as the Memphis Redbirds hung on for a 9-8 win on Saturday night at the DBAP in front of a paid attendance of 9,069. The Bulls (31-25) trailed 7-2 into the last of the eighth, but scored three
Redbirds Best Bulls 12-2
The Memphis Redbirds scored nine times in the second inning, then coasted to a 12-2 win over the Durham Bulls at the DBAP on Friday night. Thirteen Redbirds (30-23) batters came to the plate to break the game open. The first six reached with two walks, three hits and an
Murray, Bulls Batter Memphis In Rain-Shortened 11-8 Win
Tanner Murray paced an 18-hit attack by going 4-for-5 as the Durham Bulls claimed a rain-abridged, seven inning 11-8 win over the Memphis Redbirds on Thursday night at the DBAP. Murray had three singles and a double, while Jamie Westbrook was 3-4 with a homer, Coco Montes went 3-4 and
Memphis Tops Durham 7-2
Michael Siani homered to lead off the game to lead the Memphis Redbirds past the Durham Bulls 7-2 at the DBAP on Wednesday night. The Bulls (30-23), who dropped their fifth of their last six games, were handcuffed by Memphis (29-22) starter Michael McGreevy (W, 6-1) most of the night.
Redbirds Best Bulls 6-1
Luken Baker homered twice and drove in four to lead the Memphis Redbirds past the Durham Bulls 6-1 on Memorial Day at the DBAP. Baker drilled a three-run homer against Durham reliever Antonio Menendez (L, 1-1) in the third. Baker hit his second of the game in the ninth against
Worcester Defeats Durham 3-1
The Worcester Red Sox scored three times in the second inning en route to defeating the Durham Bulls 3-1 at Polar Park in the series finale Sunday afternoon. The WooSox (25-25) strung three consecutive one-out singles against Joe Rock (L, 1-4) to load the bases before a sac fly from
Bulls Split Twinbill With Red Sox
Durham hit three homers in the nightcap to salvage a doubleheader split with Worcester on Saturday night, winning 7-3 after dropping the opener 2-1 at Polar Park. Brock Jones, Andrew Stevenson and Bob Seymour each homered in game two as the Bulls (30-20) overcame an early 1-0 deficit to pick
Red Sox Top Bulls 5-4, Game 2 of Twinbill Postponed
Vaughn Grisson singled home the winning run with two outs in the seventh inning to lift the Worcester Red Sox past the Durham Bulls 5-4 in game one of Friday's doubleheader at Polar Park. The second game was subsequently postponed due to rain. The Bulls (29-19) led 4-3 with two
Williams, Westbrook Blast Bulls Past Red Sox 7-4 In Ten
Jamie Westbrook hit a game-tying home run in the ninth, then Carson Williams drilled a three-run shot in the 10th to lift the Durham Bulls past the Worcester Red Sox 7-4 at Polar Park on Wednesday night. The Bulls (29-18) were trailing 4-3 in the ninth when the former WooSox
Red Sox Best Bulls 8-2
Brian Van Belle threw seven solid innings to lift the Worcester Red Sox past the Durham Bulls 8-2 in the series opener on Tuesday night at Polar Park. Van Belle (W, 2-1) permitted just one run on four hits to pick up his second win of the season. Joe Boyle
Joe Boyle Named IL Pitcher of the Week For Second Time in 2025
Minor League Baseball on Monday announced their weekly Player and Pitcher of the Week honors for the time frame between May 12-18, with right-hander Joe Boyle being named the International League's Pitcher of the Week for the second time this season. Boyle fired 5.0 scoreless frames of one-hit ball to