Every 2024 Rule 5 Draft pick, plus 1st-round analysis
DALLAS -- Arms were on the menu during Wednesday afternoon’s Rule 5 Draft at the Winter Meetings. A total of 15 players were taken in the Major League phase of this year’s Rule 5 and 11 of them were pitchers. It started when the White Sox took right-hander Shane Smith
DALLAS -- Arms were on the menu during Wednesday afternoon’s Rule 5 Draft at the Winter Meetings. A total of 15 players were taken in the Major League phase of this year’s Rule 5 and 11 of them were pitchers. It started when the White Sox took right-hander Shane Smith from the Brewers, and five of the first six selections all will try to make big league pitching staffs in the spring.
The Triple-A phase was particularly busy, with 68 total selections made. The 83 overall picks made were the most since the 2004 Rule 5 Draft.
Players who turned pro at age 18 or younger in 2020 or at age 19 or older in 2021 were eligible for selection in the Major League phase of the Rule 5 Draft if he wasn't on a 40-man roster. Clubs who took a player in that phase must pay his former team $100,000 and keep him on their active big league roster throughout the following season. The player can't be sent to the Minors without first clearing waivers and then getting offered back to his original organization for half his draft price.
It costs $24,000 to take a player in the Triple-A phase, with no restrictions about where those players can be placed in 2025.
Smith, a Wake Forest product who signed with the Brewers as an undrafted free agent in July of 2021, will pitch all of the 2025 season at age 25. Injuries slowed him early in his career, but he had 10 saves and a 1.96 ERA in 38 relief appearances, reaching Double-A in 2023. He totaled 94 1/3 innings last season, getting time as both a starter and reliever, finishing with a combined 3.05 ERA, a .204 batting average against and 10.8 K/9 rate across Double- and Triple-A. He can miss bats with his 93-94 mph fastball and he has a distinct curve and slider, getting good extension and generally being around the strike zone (2.8 BB/9 last year).
“When we talked about him before the protection deadline we knew he was a really good pitcher, a high-character pitcher we’ve liked going back to college,” Brewers special assistant to scouting Bryan Gale said. “Anyone that’s seen him when he’s been healthy in pro baseball [sees that] he’s been successful and he’s gotten better every year. When you have to make a tough decision like that, you know there’s some risk of losing a really good player. Everyone is happy Shane will get this opportunity, and we’re all pulling for him.”
Liam Hicks was the No. 2 pick, and the one position player taken among the top half dozen, nabbed by the Marlins from the Tigers, who didn’t have him very long. A 2021 ninth-rounder out of Arkansas State, Hicks is a catcher whom the Tigers just acquired from the Rangers at this past year’s Trade Deadline. He’ll get the opportunity to serve as the Marlins’ backup receiver behind Nick Fortes.
📩 SUBSCRIBE TO THE BASEBALL TRAVELER NEWSLETTER
Major League phase
Round 1
1. White Sox: Shane Smith, RHP (from Brewers)
2. Marlins: Liam Hicks, C (Tigers)
3. Angels: Garrett McDaniels, LHP (Dodgers, now LAA No. 29)
4. Athletics: Noah Murdock, RHP (Royals)
5. Nationals: Evan Reifert, RHP (Rays, now WSH No. 26)
6. Blue Jays: Angel Bastardo, RHP (Red Sox, now TOR No. 29)
7. Reds: Cooper Bowman, 2B (was ATH No. 20, now CIN No. 26)
8. Rays: Nathan Lavender, LHP (Mets)
9. Twins: Eiberson Castellano, RHP (Phillies, now MIN No. 13)
10. Cubs: Gage Workman, 3B/SS (was DET No. 29, now CHC No. 29)
11. Braves: Anderson Pilar, RHP (Marlins)
12. Padres: Juan Nuñez, RHP (was BAL No. 8, now SD No. 11)
13. Brewers: Connor Thomas, LHP (Cardinals, now MIL No. 30)
14. Phillies: Mike Vasil, RHP (was Mets No. 18, traded to TB)
Round 2
15. Braves: Christian Cairo, SS (Guardians)
The run on pitching really got going after Hicks, with the Angels taking lefty Garrett McDaniels from the Dodgers, the A’s nabbing right-hander Noah Murdock from the Royals, the Nationals selecting Evan Reifert from the Rays and right-hander Angel Bastardo going from the Red Sox to the Blue Jays. McDaniels spent most of the year in A-ball, but finished it in Double-A, posting a combined 3.19 ERA, a .229 BAA and 10.3 K/9 rate. Like Smith, he was a 2021 undrafted free agent who signed while rehabbing from Tommy John surgery.
“He’s a good arm and can spin two breaking balls,” Angels general manager Perry Minasian said about McDaniels. “He’s 94-95 mph with a good combination of strikeouts and ground balls. He was at a lower level but stuff is stuff, so we … felt like it was worth taking the shot. Left-handed relief is hard to get. There's a chance things work out and he makes the team, and he sticks, maybe starts down the road.”
Right-hander Juan Nuñez was the highest-ranked prospect taken in the Major League phase, with the Padres taking the Orioles’ No. 8 prospect. Another righty, Mike Vasil (Mets No. 18), was taken by the Phillies and traded to the Rays. Second baseman Cooper Bowman (A’s No. 20) and infielder Gage Workman (Tigers No. 29) were the other ranked prospects to change hands.
With the acquisition of Vasil, the Rays actually secured two Mets pitching prospects on Wednesday. The first was lefty Nathan Lavender, who appeared in just five games in 2024 due to an elbow injury that resulted in internal brace surgery. He’s slated to begin the year on the 60-day injured list.
“We’ve always liked him,” Rays assistant GM Kevin Ibach said. “I say this a lot when we execute trades, but we start history with a player coming out of the Draft, coming into professional baseball. With Nate, it was a left-handed arm that we liked a lot. Multiple pitches to get guys out, like the fastball, like the deception that he provides from the left-hand side.
“Obviously would like a healthy version of the player, but this was an opportunity to get someone that we can take over the throwing program, get him into Spring Training and develop under our hood until he’s ready to take the mound again.”
If Vasil sticks, it will be because he could potentially fill different roles. He’s largely started in his career, but don’t be surprised if the Rays employ him in different ways.
“The versatility he provides with that profile is probably what’s most appealing for him,” Ibach said. “There are a lot of different ways he can impact a 26-man roster, more so than just a traditional reliever.”
The Braves joined the Rays as the only team to acquire two players, taking righty Anderson Pillar from the Marlins and making the only Round 2 selection when they took infielder Christian Cairo from the Guardians. Other than the Mets, the Tigers were the only team to lose more than one player in the Major League phase, and both were position players in Hicks and Workman.
Minor League phase
Round 1
1. White Sox: Joseph Yabbour, RHP (Mets Single-A)
2. Rockies: Tyler Burch, RHP (Orioles Double-A)
3. Marlins: Ricky DeVito, RHP (Rangers Double-A)
4. Angels: Gustavo Rodriguez, RHP (A's Double-A)
5. Athletics: Henry Gomez, RHP (Cardinals Single-A)
6. Nationals: Hyun-il Choi, RHP (Dodgers Double-A)
7. Blue Jays: Richard Gallardo, RHP (Cubs Double-A)
8. Pirates: Franck De La Rosa, RHP (Athletics Double-A)
9. Reds: Joel Valdez, LHP (Yankees High-A)
10. Giants: CJ Widger, LHP (Padres Double-A)
11. Rays: Dan Hammer, RHP (Orioles Double-A)
12. Red Sox: Hobie Harris, RHP (Mets Double-A)
13. Twins: Trent Baker, RHP (Cardinals Double-A)
14. Cardinals: Oddanier Mosqueda, LHP (Yankees Double-A)
15. Cubs: William Jensen, RHP (Giants Double-A)
16. Mariners: Cesar Quintas, OF (Giants Double-A)
17. Royals: Bryan Gonzalez, OF (Red Sox Double-A)
18. Tigers: Junior Tilien, SS (Mets High-A)
19. Astros: Julio Rodriguez, RHP (Giants Double-A)
20. Mets: Michael Hobbs, RHP (Dodgers Double-A)
21. D-backs: Drake Osborn, C (Mets Double-A)
22. Braves: Blane Abeyta, RHP (Yankees High-A)
23. Guardians: Will Wilson, SS (Giants Double-A)
24. Padres: Eiker Huizi, RHP (Tigers High-A)
25. Brewers: Garrett Spain, OF (Blue Jays Double-A)
26. Yankees: Luis Durango, OF (Guardians Single-A)
27. Phillies: Eduardo Lopez, OF (Red Sox High-A)
28. Dodgers: John Rhodes, OF (Orioles Double-A)
Round 2
29. Rockies: Jose Torres, SS (Reds Double-A)
30. Marlins: Jack Winkler, SS (Athletics Double-A)
31. Angels: Josh Crouch, C (Tigers Double-A)
32. Blue Jays: Jacob Wetzel, OF (Cubs High-A)
33. Pirates: Aaron McKeithan, C (Cardinals Double-A)
34. Reds: Brandon Komar, RHP (Cardinals Double-A)
35. Giants: Sadrac Franco, RHP (Tigers Single-A)
36. Red Sox: Darvin Garcia, RHP (Pirates High-A)
37. Twins: Miguel Briceno, SS (Brewers Double-A)
38. Cardinals: Angel Gonzalez, RHP (Cubs High-A)
39. Cubs: Nolan Clenney, RHP (Mets Double-A)
40. Mariners: Taylor Floyd, RHP (Twins Double-A)
41. Royals: Landon Marceaux, RHP (Mets Single-A)
42. Astros: Jean Pinto, RHP (Orioles Double-A)
43. Braves: Samuel Mejia, RHP (Rays Single-A)
44. Padres: Jake Snider, OF (Rockies High-A)
45. Brewers: Zachary Peek, RHP (Orioles Double-A)
46. Phillies: Enmanuel Mejia, RHP (Rays Double-A)
Round 3
47. Orlando Ortiz-Mayr, RHP (Dodgers Double-A)
48. Pirates: Randy Labaut, LHP (Guardians Double-A)
49. Red Sox: Manuel Medina, LHP (Marlins Single-A)
50. Twins: Jefferson Valladares, C (Dodgers Complex League)
51. Cardinals: Jawilme Ramirez, RHP (Mets High-A)
52. Cubs: Robert Kwiatkowski, RHP (Red Sox Double-A)
53. Mariners: Adam Leverett, RHP (Rays Double-A)
54. Astros: Anderson Bido, RHP (Rockies Double-A)
55. Braves: Lizandro Espinoza, SS (Cardinals Single-A)
56. Padres: Andy Thomas, C (Giants Double-A)
57. Phillies: Agusto Calderon, RHP (Cardinals Single-A)
Round 4
58. Pirates: Steve Hajjar, LHP (Guardians Double-A)
59. Red Sox: Jack Anderson, RHP (Tigers Double-A)
60. Cardinals: Miguel Ugueto, OF (Red Sox High-A)
61. Mariners: Matt Cronin, LHP (Nationals Double-A)
62. Astros: Jack Blomgren, SS (Rockies High-A)
63. Braves: Dylan Shockley, C (Pirates Double-A)
64: Phillies: Elio Prado, OF (Orioles High-A)
Round 5
65: Pirates: Joel Mendez, OF (Yankees Complex League)
66. Astros: Nick Swiney, LHP (Giants Double-A)
67. Phillies: Gabriel Barbosa, RHP (Yankees Single-A)
Round 6
68. Phillies: Isaias Dipre, INF (Pirates DSL)
Jonathan Mayo is a reporter for MLBPipeline.com. Follow him on Facebook and @JonathanMayo, and listen to him on the weekly MLB Pipeline Podcast.
Looking back at Voit's astounding August 2016
Yankees fans have gotten used to the power and production Luke Voit provides in the Bronx. But fans of the Double-A Springfield Cardinals got an early look at Voit's talents toward the end of the 2016 campaign.
Recent noteworthy Texas League performances
This space started honoring the short-season leagues after their respective campaigns were delayed in June. Now following the cancellation of all Minor League Baseball in 2020, we're turning it into an appreciation of the full-season circuits as well. So Toolshed is revisiting the 10 most notable individual seasons put together
Dudley Field played home to historic outburst
No place in Minor League Baseball history provided the spectacle that El Paso's Dudley Field did regularly in its heyday. At an elevation of more than 4,000 feet, the dry desert air and constant high winds combined with quirky outfield dimensions made the stadium a launching pad for baseballs. Throw
A well-trodden road: Travelers pass test of time
With so much focus year after year on the newest and wildest rebranding projects in Minor League Baseball, MiLB.com takes a look at the flip side. This spring and summer, we will be profiling teams with some of the longest continually used nicknames in each league. Next up: the Texas
Wellman following in father's footsteps
At first glance, it doesn't seem like much is amiss at HODGETOWN in Amarillo, Texas. There's a baseball game being played on the diamond, complete with scoreboard updates and sound effects. Socially distanced fans are spread throughout the confines or basking in the sun beyond the outfield grass. Even broadcaster
2020 Minor League Baseball season shelved
ST. PETERSBURG, Fla. -- Major League Baseball™ (MLB™) has informed Minor League Baseball™ (MiLB™) that it will not be providing its affiliated Minor League teams with players for the 2020 season. As a result, there will not be a Minor League Baseball season in 2020. "These are unprecedented times for
Did you know? Texas League edition
When it comes to size, scope and longevity, few, if any, sporting bodies can rival Minor League Baseball. With 160 teams in nearly as many markets, there are innumerable nooks and crannies to explore. This marks the fourth installment in a series dedicated to such explorations, providing one unique, weird,
Fort Worth Cats became legends of the game
Some of the names you know. You can picture their faces: Rogers Hornsby. Duke Snider. Sparky Anderson. Maury Wills. Dick Williams. Others are perhaps less familiar, but they're also a part of baseball history: Bobby Bragan. Billy Hunter. Danny Ozark.The Fort Worth Cats were mainstays of the Texas League for
Hoskins broke barriers in Texas League
April 15, 1947 might be baseball's moment to cherish, but the historical significance of that date transcends the sport. When Jackie Robinson stepped onto the diamond on a chilly spring afternoon at Brooklyn's Ebbets Field as a member of the Dodgers, he left an indelible mark not only on the
Update from Texas League president Tim Purpura
NORTH RICHLAND HILLS, Texas - In response to the COVID-19 outbreak across the country and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and World Health Organization's (WHO) recent declarations, the start of the 2020 Minor League Baseball season, which includes the Double-A Texas League of Professional Baseball Clubs, has been delayed.
Betts trade official with addition of Downs
Baseball's blockbuster trade is finally official with the key addition of Dodgers' shortstop Jeter Downs. Downs, MLB.com's No. 44 overall prospect, and catcher Connor Wong were added to the deal that sends 2018 American League MVP Mookie Betts, left-hander David Price and cash from the Red Sox to the Dodgers. The trade was finalized
Ex-'Riders broadcaster blazing new path
Growing up, Ryan Rouillard often heard from his mother that life is like a book. It contains many pages, characters and plot points, all of which come together to form metaphorical chapters representing the stages of one's personal story. All things considered, Rouillard's book has been pretty kind to him
Amarillo's Ensor named 2019 Texas League Executive of Year
FORT WORTH, Texas -- Amarillo Sod Poodles' President and General Manager Tony Ensor has been selected as the 2019 Bill Valentine Texas League Executive of the Year, according to an announcement made by TL President Tim Purpura.The award, which recognizes a successful season in the areas of leadership, attendance, marketing
Dodgers tab Lux top Minor League player
Gavin Lux and Josiah Gray -- two of the Dodgers' premier prospects -- have received player-of-the-year honors from the club.MLB.com's No. 2 overall prospect, Lux batted .347/.421/.607 with 26 homers, 99 runs and 76 RBIs across two levels en route to garnering the Branch Rickey Minor League Player of the
Trammell, Poodles win Texas League title
TULSA, Okla. -- Amarillo had squandered its share of opportunities but wasn't about to let another one pass them by with the Texas League championship on the line.After loading the bases with nobody out in the fifth inning and coming away empty, then loading them again and scoring just once
Reed, Poodles knot Texas League Finals
There will be a winner-take-all Game 5 for the Texas League banner.No. 25 San Diego prospectBuddy Reed went yard as Double-A Amarillo blanked Tulsa, 3-0, on Saturday night at ONEOK Field in Game 4 of the Championship Series.
Wong drives Drillers one win from crown
Offense dominated the first two games of the Texas League Championship Series, but the outcome of Game 3 was determined by one swing of the bat.Dodgers No. 28 prospectConnor Wong hammered a two-run homer in the bottom of the sixth inning, powering Tulsa to a 2-0 win over Amarillo on
Tulsa evens TL Finals on Downs' trifecta
Jeter Downs set the tone for the Double-A Drillers with a milestone night. The sixth-ranked Dodgers prospect smacked three solo homers, reached base six times and scored five runs as Tulsa outslugged Amarillo, 18-9, in Game 2 of the Texas League Championship Series at Hodgetown. Donovan Casey added two dingers,
Olivares steps up for Poodles in Game 1
Edward Olivares came through Double-A Amarillo in a big way Tuesday night.San Diego's No. 17 prospect delivered a go-ahead three-run double in the eighth inning as the Sod Poodles pulled away for a 13-6 victory over Tulsa at Hodgetown in Game 1 of the best-of-5 Texas League Championship Series. Olivares
Trammell propels Amarillo to Texas Finals
In their first year of existence, the Amarillo Sod Poodles are headed to the Texas League Finals.Second-ranked Padres prospectTaylor Trammell went 2-for-3 with a walk and a run scored as Amarillo built an early lead and held on to beat Midland, 7-5, in the deciding Game 5 of the semifinals
Lewis' heroics help keep Travelers alive
With Arkansas' season hanging in the balance, Kyle Lewis helped extend it with one swing of the bat.The 10th-ranked Mariners prospect hit a go-ahead solo homer and singled as the Travelers forced a decisive fifth game in the Texas League semifinals with a 4-1 triumph over Tulsa on Saturday night at
Trammell, Sod Poodles extend TL semis
Double-A Amarillo had its back against the wall coming into Friday's game against Midland, and it didn't help when the RockHounds went up 1-0 in the first inning. But Taylor Trammell and the Sod Poodles weren't going to go down that easy.The Padres' No. 2 prospect went 3-for-5 with an
Deichmann provides power for Midland
Greg Deichmann and Double-A Midland have spent the last 11 days on the road, but he hasn't needed any home cooking to keep his end-of-year power surge going.The No. 17 Athletics prospect mashed two home runs and collected three RBIs to guide the RockHounds to a 4-1 victory over Amarillo
Raleigh, bullpen pace Arkansas in semis
Cal Raleigh didn't record a hit in the Texas League semifinals opener, but he helped Double-A Arkansas take the edge in the series. The seventh-ranked Mariners prospect walked and scored the winning run in the eighth inning and the Travelers bullpen posted four hitless innings in Arkansas' 2-1 victory over Tulsa