Postseason All-Star Teams
| Post-Season All-Star Teams |
| 2012 | |
| First Baseman | Ernesto Mejia (Gwinnett) |
| Second Baseman | Cord Phelps (Columbus) |
| Shortstop | Jose Iglesias (Pawtucket) |
| Third Baseman | Carlos Rivero (Syracuse) |
| Catcher | Ryan Lavarnway (Pawtucket) |
| Designated Hitter | Mauro Gomez (Pawtucket) |
| Outfielders | Leslie Anderson (Durham), Corey Brown (Syracuse), Starling Marte (Indianapolis) |
| Utility Player | Dan Johnson (Charlotte) |
| Starting Pitcher | Tyler Cloyd (Lehigh Valley) |
| Relief Pitcher | Tim Wood (Indianapolis) |
| 2011 | |
| First Baseman | Matt Hague (Indianapolis) |
| Second Baseman | Jason Kipnis (Columbus) |
| Shortstop | Zack Cozart (Louisville) |
| Third Baseman | Russ Canzler (Durham) |
| Catcher | Devin Mesoraco (Louisville) |
| Designated Hitter | Jorge Vazquez (Scranton/WB) |
| Outfielders | Stefan Gartrell (Gwinnett), Alex Presley (Indianapolis), Dayan Viciedo (Charlotte) |
| Utility Player | Luis Valbuena (Columbus) |
| Starting Pitcher | Julio Teheran (Gwinnett) |
| Relief Pitcher | Tim Wood (Indianapolis) |
| 2010 | |
| First Baseman | Freddie Freeman (Gwinnett) |
| Second Baseman | Chris Valaika (Louisville) |
| Shortstop | Eduardo Nunez (Scranton/WB) |
| Third Baseman | Dan Johnson (Durham) |
| Catcher | Jesus Montero (Scranton/WB) |
| Designated Hitter | Barbaro Canizares (Gwinnett) |
| Outfielders | Wladimir Balentein (Louisville), Jose Constanza (Columbus), Jeff Frazier (Toledo) |
| Utility Player | Elliot Johnson (Durham) |
| Starting Pitcher | Jeremy Hellickson (Durham) |
| Relief Pitcher | Jonathan Albaladejo (Scranton/WB) |
| 2009 | |
| First Baseman | Andy Tracy (Lehigh Valley) |
| Second Baseman | Kevin Russo (Scranton/Wilkes-Barre) |
| Shortstop | Brent Dlugach (Toledo) |
| Third Baseman | Andy Marte (Columbus) |
| Catcher | Erik Kratz (Indianapolis) |
| Designated Hitter | Barbaro Canizares (Gwinnett) |
| Outfielders | Jordan Brown (Columbus), Shelley Duncan (Scranton/Wilkes-Barre), Jon Weber (Durham) |
| Utility Player | Don Kelly (Toledo) |
| Starting Pitcher | Carlos Torres (Charlotte) |
| Relief Pitcher | Luiz Valdez (Gwinnett) |
| 2008 | |
| First Baseman | Oscar Salazar (Norfolk) |
| Second Baseman | Joe Thurston (Pawtucket) |
| Shortstop | Reid Brignac (Durham) |
| Third Baseman | Mike Hessman (Toledo) |
| Catcher | Ryan Hanigan (Louisville) |
| Designated Hitter | Brad Eldred (Charlotte) |
| Outfielders | Josh Anderson (Richmond), Jeff Bailey (Pawtucket), Chris Carter (Pawtucket) |
| Utility Player | Chris Getz (Charlotte) |
| Starting Pitcher | Charlie Zink (Pawtucket) |
| Relief Pitcher | Blaine Neal (Toledo) |
| 2007 | |
| First Baseman | Joey Votto (Louisville) |
| Second Baseman | Martin Prado (Richmond) |
| Shortstop | Brian Bixler (Indianapolis) |
| Third Baseman | Mike Hessman (Toledo) |
| Catcher | Jose Morales (Rochester) |
| Designated Hitter | Shelley Duncan (Scranton/WB) |
| Outfielders | Timo Perez (Toledo), Ben Francisco (Buffalo), Justin Ruggiano (Durham) |
| Utility Player | Aaron Herr (Louisville) |
| Starting Pitcher | Kevin Slowey (Rochester) |
| Relief Pitcher | Cory Doyne (Norfolk) |
| 2006 | |
| First Baseman | Kevin Witt (Durham) |
| Second Baseman | Joe Thurston (Scranton/WB) |
| Shortstop | Jorge Velandia (Charlotte) |
| Third Baseman | Josh Fields (Charlotte) |
| Catcher | Carlos Ruiz (Scranton/WB) |
| Designated Hitter | Josh Phelps (Toledo) |
| Outfielders | Jason Dubois (Buffalo), Norris Hopper (Louisville), Darnell McDonald (Durham) |
| Utility Player | Dustin Pedroia (Pawtucket) |
| Starting Pitcher | Heath Phillips (Charlotte) |
| Relief Pitcher | Pat Neshek (Rochester) |
| 2005 | |
| First Baseman | Mitch Jones (Columbus) |
| Second Baseman | Bernie Castro (Ottawa) |
| Shortstop | B.J. Upton (Durham) |
| Third Baseman | Edwin Encarnacion (Louisville) |
| Catcher | Kelly Shoppach (Pawtucket) |
| Designated Hitter | Brian Daubach (Norfolk) |
| Outfielders | John-Ford Griffin (Syracuse), Curtis Granderson (Toledo), Shane Victorino (Scranton/WB) |
| Utility Player | Ryan Garko (Buffalo) |
| Starting Pitcher | Zach Duke (Indianapolis) |
| Relief Pitcher | Travis Bowyer (Rochester) |
| 2004 | |
| First Baseman | Justin Morneau (Rochester) |
| Second Baseman | Pete Orr (Richmond) |
| Shortstop | Jhonny Peralta (Buffalo) |
| Third Baseman | Earl Snyder (Louisville) |
| Catcher | Kelly Shoppach (Pawtucket) |
| Designated Hitter | Ernie Young (Buffalo) |
| Outfielders | Matt Diaz (Durham), Adam Hyzdu (Pawtucket), Jason Kubel (Rochester) |
| Utility Player | Jorge Cantu (Durham) |
| Starting Pitcher | Ben Hendrickson (Indianapolis) |
| Relief Pitcher | Matt Whiteside (Richmond) |
| 2003 | |
| First Baseman | Ross Gload (Charlotte) |
| Second Baseman | Chase Utley (Scranton/Wilkes-Barre) |
| Shortstop | Jason Smith (Durham) |
| Third Baseman | Brandon Larson (Louisville) |
| Catcher | Johnny Estrada (Richmond) |
| Designated Hitter | Fernando Seguignol (Columbus) |
| Outfielders | Andy Abad (Pawtucket), Lou Collier (Pawtucket), Alex Escobar (Buffalo) |
| Utility Player | Ryan Jackson (Durham) |
| Starting Pitcher | Bronson Arroyo (Pawtucket) |
| Relief Pitcher | Fernando Rodney (Toledo) |
| 2002 | |
| First Baseman | Joe Vitiello (Ottawa) |
| Second Baseman | Marco Scutaro (Norfolk) |
| Shortstop | Nick Punto (Scranton/Wilkes-Barre) |
| Third Baseman | Joe Crede (Charlotte) |
| Catcher | Johnny Estrada (Scranton/Wilkes-Barre) |
| Designated Hitter | Kevin Witt (Louisville) |
| Outfielders | Marlon Byrd (Scranton/Wilkes-Barre), Endy Chavez (Ottawa), Raul Gonzalez (Louisville) |
| Utility Player | David Doster (Scranton/Wilkes-Barre) |
| Starting Pitcher | Joe Roa (Scranton/Wilkes-Barre) |
| Relief Pitcher | Lee Gardner (Durham) |
| 2001 | |
| First Baseman | Calvin Pickering (Rochester) |
| Second Baseman | P.J. Forbes (Scranton/Wilkes-Barre) |
| Shortstop | Cesar Izturis (Syracuse) |
| Third Baseman | Kevin Orie (Scranton/Wilkes-Barre) |
| Catcher | Toby Hall (Durham) |
| Designated Hitter | Izzy Alcantara (Pawtucket) |
| Outfielders | Karim Garcia (Buffalo), Eric Valent (Scranton/Wilkes-Barre), Chris Wakeland (Toledo) |
| Utility Player | Brian Rios (Toledo) |
| Starting Pitcher | Brandon Duckworth (Scranton/Wilkes-Barre) |
| Relief Pitcher | Matt DeWitt (Syracuse) |
| 2000 | |
| First Baseman | Ryan Jackson (Durham) |
| Second Baseman | Marlon Anderson (Scranton/Wilkes-Barre) |
| Shortstop | Chris Sexton (Louisville) |
| Third Baseman | Aubrey Huff (Durham) |
| Catcher | Gary Bennett (Scranton/Wilkes-Barre) |
| Designated Hitter | Luis Lopez (Syracuse) |
| Outfielders | Chad Mottola (Syracuse), Billy McMillon (Toledo), Ozzie Timmons (Durham) |
| Utility Player | Bill Selby (Buffalo) |
| Starting Pitcher | Jon Garland (Charlotte) |
| Relief Pitcher | Bob Scanlan (Indianapolis) |