Ben's Best: Favorite stadiums, level by level

After visiting every park, MiLB.com scribe shares top experiences

Southwest University Park, which opened in 2014, shows off the region's natural beauty and hosts a vibrant fan base. (El Paso Chihuahuas)

By Benjamin Hill / MiLB.com | October 18, 2018 10:30 AM

Last month, after stops in Colorado Springs and Grand Junction, MiLB.com's Ben Hill completed his #BenEverywhere goal of having visited all 159 active affiliated Minor League Baseball ballparks. He's visited 172 Minor League Ballparks overall, many of them multiple times. This marks the first in a series of "Ben's Best" articles, in which Hill recaps his favorite people, places and things from his many seasons of professional travel.

Exploring America through Minor League Baseball is a big part of my job. As a result, I've become accustomed to fielding the following question on a regular basis: 

"What's your favorite ballpark?" 

This query, while understandable, has always frustrated me. The variety of Minor League Baseball ballparks is indicative of the variety of the American landscape. How can one reasonably compare a shining downtown shrine in a large Triple-A market with a historic Rookie-level facility located in a small town and overseen by a full-time staff of one? And what criteria go into determining a "favorite," anyway? Factors include but are not limited to architecture, the appeal of the surrounding area, the experience provided by the front office staff, culinary options and the fervor of the fan base. And, even after all that, it's still just a matter of taste. 

In order to answer this long-vexing question while mitigating some of the discrepancies detailed above, I have decided to list my favorite ballparks by level of play. It was still a thankless task, full of both metaphorical and actual teeth-gnashing and hair-pulling, exacerbated by the knowledge that my choices -- and, by extension, anyone's choices -- are sure to result in reactions of incredulous disdain from those who disagree. By and large, I'm a fan of the classics. I didn't quite realize how much so until I was putting this article together. But I'm looking forward to teams and fans telling me why my choices are not, in fact, correct. That's what makes this fun.   

Triple-A: Southwest University Park (home of the El Paso Chihuahuas, Pacific Coast League)
Opened: 2014
Visited: 2014
El Paso is a border town, and Southwest University Park encapsulates the blend of Mexican and American culture that typifies life in the West Texas city. The Chihuahuas name is a reference not just to the small dog, but to the Chihuahuan Desert that encompasses both West Texas and a substantial part of Northern Mexico. The Franklin Mountains loom beyond the park's left field fence, the El Paso skyline is visible to the right and the sprawling, mountainous Juarez, Mexico, cityscape hovers just beyond the home plate side of the stadium. Interesting architectural components -- such as the three-story "Big Dog House" in right field -- make the park itself a memorable place to explore, and the multicultural fan base provides a livelier-than-usual Minor League game day atmosphere. As if all this wasn't enough, you're unlikely to find a wider array of authentic Mexican cuisine at any American sports facility, anywhere.
Honorable Mentions: BB&T Park (Charlotte Knights); Durham Bulls Athletic Park (Durham Bulls); Fifth Third Field (Toledo Mud Hens)

Double-A: First Energy Stadium (home of the Reading Fightin Phils, Eastern League)
Opened: 1951
Visited: 2017
Sixty-seven-year-old First Energy Stadium is perhaps the premier example of a "best of both worlds" Minor League atmosphere, in which an old ballpark retains its throwback charm while offering a modern entertainment experience. Reading has been a Philadelphia affiliate since 1967, and the long history and convenient proximity between the two organizations results in a fan base that is both passionate and knowledgeable. The same goes for the front office staff, which has featured far less turnover than is typical in the industry. A night at First Energy Stadium is imbued with the past, but, somewhat paradoxically, not weighed down by the no-distractions dogma of the baseball purist. This is a ballpark rife with color and characters, set against a bucolic Berks County backdrop. Presiding over it all is the ostrich-riding Crazy Hot Dog Vendor, a bespectacled local hero whose antics are complemented by a literal band of mascots; they occasionally bang out classic rock 'n' roll covers from a stage located on the first base side of the ballpark. A Fightin Phils game is equal parts sporting event and county fair, a sensory overload mash-up of the traditional and idiosyncratic that, somehow, all seems to make sense. Welcome to Baseballtown. 
Honorable Mentions: Dunkin' Donuts Park (Hartford Yard Goats), Dr Pepper Ballpark (Frisco RoughRiders), Blue Wahoos Stadium (Pensacola Blue Wahoos)

Class A Advanced: Jackie Robinson Ballpark (home of the Daytona Tortugas, Florida State League)
Opened: 1914
Visited: 2018
Most Florida State League ballparks aren't exactly Minor League ballparks, per se, but Spring Training facilities occupied by Minor League teams after their parent clubs depart in March. Daytona Beach's Jackie Robinson Ballpark is the circuit's most notable exception, as it is a classic facility, located on an actual island, with charm and style to spare. The majority of fans sit in a covered grandstand under a rooftop press box, with views of Broadway Bridge spanning the Halifax River. The lively concourse, abutted by lime green exterior walls, includes the Bob Ross "Happy Little Tree" (planted in honor of the Daytona Beach native) as well as an interactive museum devoted to the life and times of stadium namesake Jackie Robinson. The baseball trailblazer spent the 1946 Spring Training in Daytona Beach as the city ignored Jim Crow segregation laws to let him play his first games as a member of the Brooklyn Dodgers organization. The ballpark was renamed in his honor in 1990; that same year, a Jackie Robinson statue was erected outside of the ballpark.
Honorable Mentions: The Diamond (Lake Elsinore Storm), Municipal Stadium (San Jose Giants), BB&T Ballpark (Winston-Salem Dash)

Class A: McCormick Field (home of the Asheville Tourists, South Atlantic League)
Opened: 1924
Visited: 2018
In 1926, after an exhibition game at McCormick Field, Babe Ruth had this to say: "My, my, what a beautiful place to play. Delightful. Damned delightful place." Over 90 years later, the Bambino's sentiment still applies. Nestled into a hilly landscape south of downtown Asheville, McCormick Field is an anachronistic charmer. Ruth is not the only legendary slugger who played there; in "Bull Durham," Crash Davis broke the Minor League home run record as a member of the Tourists and scenes from the movie were filmed at McCormick Field. The concourse, bursting with cartoonishly decorated concession stands, exudes the sort of funky charm that Asheville has become known for. Crowds are liable to be the biggest for "Thirsty Thursday," a promotional idea that was first conceived (and later copyrighted by) the Tourists. It's a fitting claim to fame for a team that plays in a region where local breweries abound to the extent that the club occasionally changes its name to the "Beer City Tourists."
Honorable Mentions: Parkview Field (Fort Wayne TinCaps), Modern Woodmen Park (Quad Cities River Bandits), Cooley Law School Stadium (Lansing Lugnuts)

Class A Short Season: Nat Bailey Stadium (home of the Vancouver Canadians, Northwest League)
Opened: 1951
Visited: 2012
There are 160 Minor League teams playing in 159 different ballparks (the Palm Beach Cardinals and Jupiter Hammerheads share Roger Dean Chevrolet Stadium). But there's only one ballpark that an American citizen needs a passport to get to, and that is Vancouver's Nat Bailey Stadium. This 67-year-old facility hosted Triple-A Pacific Coast League baseball through 1999, shifting to the short-season Northwest League in 2000. The Canadians' mid-June through early September schedule meshes perfectly with Vancouver's climate, avoiding harsh early spring weather in favor of idyllic summertime days and nights. It all plays out in a classic baseball atmosphere that combines natural beauty with the multicultural vibrancy of one of Canada's most livable cities. Grab some sushi and an Asahi and enjoy the game.  
Honorable Mentions: MCU Park (Brooklyn Cyclones), Centennial Field (Vermont Lake Monsters), Avista Stadium (Spokane Indians)

Rookie: Bowen Field (home of the Bluefield Blue Jays, Appalachian League)
Opened: 1939
Visited: 2016
The original Bowen Field was destroyed by fire in 1973, so most of the ballpark that's in place now dates back only to 1975. Nonetheless, there's a timeless quality to this facility, a simple structure consisting mainly of a covered grandstand. Such a no-frills aesthetic is common in Rookie-ball, but Bowen Field's gorgeous background makes it stand out. A lush, gently sloping expanse of trees rises behind the outfield, the green of the foliage complementing the natural grass of the playing surface. It's a perfect home for birds; the team was an affiliate of the Orioles from 1958-2010 before switching to the Blue Jays. 
Honorable Mentions: TVA Credit Union Ballpark (Johnson City Cardinals), Calfee Park (Pulaski Yankees), Lindquist Field (Ogden Raptors)

Benjamin Hill is a reporter for MiLB.com and writes Ben's Biz Blog. Follow Ben on Twitter This story was not subject to the approval of the National Association of Professional Baseball Leagues or its clubs.

View More