Phils' Painter takes big step in TJ recovery, K's 2 in Fall League
SCOTTSDALE, Ariz. -- Sound the alarm, Andrew Painter is back on the hill. As Philadelphia’s top-ranked pitching prospect took a deep breath and threw his warmup tosses ahead of his first game action since March 2023, an ambulance siren blared outside of Scottsdale Stadium -- a moment of levity amid
SCOTTSDALE, Ariz. -- Sound the alarm, Andrew Painter is back on the hill.
As Philadelphia’s top-ranked pitching prospect took a deep breath and threw his warmup tosses ahead of his first game action since March 2023, an ambulance siren blared outside of Scottsdale Stadium -- a moment of levity amid an arduous path back to the mound.
Painter’s first step in his return from July 2023 Tommy John surgery came Saturday afternoon during Arizona Fall League play, as he took the mound with “Phillies” emblazoned across his chest. The right-hander pumped his fastball as hard as 99-100 mph during his first inning of action, which included getting rehabbing Mets infielder/outfielder Jeff McNeil to fly out and Giants top-ranked prospect Bryce Eldridge to strike out on a breaking ball.
The second inning proved more laborious for Painter: He allowed a leadoff solo homer to Tigers No. 9 prospect Josue Briceño, going on to yield an RBI later in the frame as well. In total, MLB’s No. 32 prospect threw 29 pitches (18 for strikes) and allowed two runs on three hits and one walk with a pair of strikeouts.
“I thought obviously the results weren't exactly what I wanted, but arm's healthy and that was the biggest takeaway,” Painter said. “Everything felt like it was coming out good, like my old self.”
Painter’s old self was one of the most dominant Minor League pitching prospects to come from the high school ranks in the past decade. In 109 2/3 frames across four levels, Painter struck out 167, posted a 1.48 ERA and saw batters produce a combined .507 OPS. His 70-grade heater was so dominant at the lower levels that he climbed as high as Double-A Reading as a 19-year-old.
To start 2023, Painter was MLB Pipeline’s No.1-ranked pitching prospect in all of baseball (No. 6 overall). But after just two innings of a Grapefruit League outing on March 1, 2023, he was shut down. He attempted to rehab his elbow with non-surgical measures, but by the summer, he knew it was the necessary course of action in the long term.
“More of a new chapter,” Painter said of his altered mindset. “It's a new elbow, so I'm a new person now. You can look at that stuff and think back, but I think it's just a dangerous spot to be in.”
Still just 21 years old, Painter’s gone through the gamut not just physically by having the game taken away, but mentally as well. He lauded the work done at the club’s complex alongside Dr. Traci Statler, the Phillies’ mental performance scouting and rehab coordinator.
“Baseball's been my thing growing up and it's been something I've loved,” Painter said. “Getting that taken away from me, I think it just made me appreciate the game so much more. I just really look forward to any time I get to be out here on the field and just go to the field every day.”
Painter is expected to throw around 20 innings over the coming weeks for the Glendale Desert Dogs, priming him for a chance to compete for a big league rotation spot come 2025. Despite not having consistently pitched since late 2022, when he has tossed just 28 1/3 innings at the Double-A level, the 6-foot-7 hurler is firmly on the Phillies’ radar.
“I do think he’ll be pitching at the big league level at some point in ‘25,” Phillies president of baseball operations Dave Dombrowski said earlier this week. “He’s not going to be able to go out there like a big league starter and pitch every five or six days and pitch a whole season and have 180 innings. He’s going to be limited, much more than that.
📩 CLICK HERE TO SUBSCRIBE TO BEN'S BIZ
“So how do we do that? Do we start pitching him in games later? Do we start pitching him at the Minor Leagues once a week and limit the innings? Could he pitch here? Yes, but it also depends how he does.”
“I think it was always a possibility,” Painter said of pitching in the Fall League, “but I know some of the main focus was the rehab process. It's a long process. So I think that the thought process there was kind of just be where your feet are at and live in the present and not put those goals in front until that time comes.
“End goal is always pitching in the big leagues, and pitching in the big leagues for a while.”
Jesse Borek is a reporter/coordinator of prospect content at MLB Pipeline and MiLB. Follow him on Twitter @JesseABorek.
Bullpen Struggles Doom Chiefs on Tuesday
PEORIA, IL – The Peoria Chiefs fell on Tuesday in the series opener to the Wisconsin Timber Rattlers, 14-9, after a seven-run seventh inning by Wisconsin. The Chiefs held leads of 5-0 and 8-3 but the bullpen could not keep the home club in front. Peoria pitching issued 15 walks
Chiefs Fall Despite Late Push Against Beloit
PEORIA, IL – A furious eighth-inning rally brought the Peoria Chiefs within striking distance on Sunday afternoon, but the Beloit Sky Carp held on for an 11-7 win at Dozer Park in the series finale. Down 10-2 entering the bottom of the eighth inning, Peoria sent ten men to the
Chiefs Take Advantage of Beloit Miscues, Win 6-2
PEORIA, IL – The Peoria Chiefs secured their second consecutive win Saturday night, capitalizing on five Beloit errors in a 6-2 win at Dozer Park. The Chiefs jumped out early in the bottom of the first inning. Back-to-back singles from Jon Jon Gazdar and Joshua Baez set the table, and
Rincon Dazzles in Nightcap, Chiefs Split Doubleheader
PEORIA, IL - The Peoria Chiefs and the Beloit Sky Carp split a twin bill on Friday at Dozer Park. Beloit used a sensational diving grab from shortstop Payton Green to escape with a 4-3 win in game one. In game two, the Chiefs got a measure of revenge, winning
Chiefs-Sky Carp Postponed on Thursday
PEORIA, IL - Due to wet grounds, Thursday’s contest between the Peoria Chiefs and the Beloit Sky Carp has been postponed. The two clubs will play a doubleheader on Friday. First pitch is scheduled for 5:00 p.m. at Dozer Park. Starting pitchers for Friday’s twinbill are to be determined. Fans
Missed Chances Cost Chiefs in 4-3 Loss
PEORIA, IL - The Peoria Chiefs came up just short on Wednesday night, falling to the Beloit Sky Carp 4-3 in a game defined by missed opportunities. The two teams combined to leave 23 runners on base, including 13 by the Chiefs. Peoria had multiple chances to break the game
Sky Carp Rally Past Chiefs in Slugfest, 13-9
PEORIA, IL - A fast start wasn’t enough for the Peoria Chiefs on Tuesday afternoon, as the Beloit Sky Carp used a barrage of late offense to rally for a 13-9 win at Dozer Park. Nine unanswered runs from the fourth inning on helped the Sky Carp take the opener
Bandits Edge Chiefs in Pitchers' Duel
DAVENPORT, IA – Behind another quality pitching effort, the Quad Cities River Bandits inched past the Chiefs 2-1 on Sunday. The River Bandits, who lead all of Minor League Baseball in ERA, held Peoria to just three hits in the series finale. Over the course of the week, Quad Cities
Salazar's Heroics Deliver Chiefs to 2-1 Win in Extras
DAVENPORT, IA – The Peoria Chiefs needed a feel-good win and they got one on Saturday. Johnfrank Salzar’s go-ahead double in the top of the 10th inning vaulted the Chiefs to the lead for good in a 2-1 win at Quad Cities. Peoria was staring a defeat in the face
River Bandits Knock off Chiefs on Friday
DAVENPORT, IA – The Peoria Chiefs fell to the Quad Cities River Bandits on Friday night at Modern Woodmen Park, falling in a 13-4 decision. Quad Cities racked up 18 hits to claim their second win in as many nights. It was a tough outing for Chiefs starter Jose Davila,
Bats Fall Silent in 5-0 Loss Thursday
DAVENPORT, IA – Just a day after the Chiefs held Quad Cities to two hits in a win on Wednesday, the River Bandits returned the favor on Thursday, limiting the Chiefs to two hits in a 5-0 victory. Quad Cities starter Hunter Patteson led the way with a dominant outing.
Peoria Bullpen Dominates in 5-1 Win at Quad Cities
DAVENPORT, IA – The Peoria Chiefs bullpen did not allow a hit over five shutout innings in a 5-1 win at Quad Cities on Wednesday. Right-hander Gerardo Salas set the tone early, scattering just one run over four solid innings. From there, the trio of D.J. Carpenter, Benjamin Arias and
Errors Costly as Chiefs Drop Series Opener to Quad Cities
DAVENPORT, IA – The Peoria Chiefs couldn’t overcome a tough night defensively, falling 10-3 to the Quad Cities River Bandits in the opener of a six-game series Tuesday at Modern Woodmen Park. Peoria committed five errors in the loss, as Quad Cities took advantage at nearly every turn. A brief
Chiefs-Kernels Banged on Sunday, Make-Up to be Determined
PEORIA, IL – Sunday’s series finale against the Cedar Rapids Kernels was postponed due to rain. The game will be returned to Cedar Rapids, as the Kernels do not return to Peoria in the first half of the season. The make-up date is to be determined. Tickets for Sunday’s game
Kernels Sweep Pair from Chiefs
PEORIA, IL – The Cedar Rapids Kernels swept a doubleheader from the Chiefs on Saturday, winning 13-6 in the completion of Friday’s suspended game and 4-1 in the nightcap at Dozer Park. GAME ONE: The Peoria Chiefs fell to Cedar Rapids, 13–6, in game one of Saturday’s doubleheader, a contest
Rain Halts Play at Dozer Park Friday Night
PEORIA, IL – Friday night’s game between the Peoria Chiefs and Cedar Rapids Kernels was suspended in the top of the fourth inning due to rain. Play was halted at 8:08 p.m. and officially suspended at 9:14 p.m., with the Kernels leading 8–3 with two outs in the fourth. The
Bullpen Dazzles, Offense Stays Hot in 9-4 Win
PEORIA, IL – The Chiefs bullpen scattered just one earned tally over 7 ⅓ innings on Thursday, while the Peoria offense again brought the lumber in a 9-4 triumph over the Cedar Rapids Kernels. Peoria got a lift from a new face in former Kernels pitcher Ricardo Velez. The right-hander
Kernels Edge Chiefs in Seesaw Affair
PEORIA, IL – The Peoria Chiefs fell short on Wednesday night, losing 8–7 in 11 innings to the Cedar Rapids Kernels at Dozer Park. Despite an early lead and a big offensive response in the middle innings, the Chiefs couldn’t hold off the Kernels' late push. Peoria struck first in
Chiefs Plate Six Unanswered, Pop Kernels
PEORIA, IL – After falling behind early on Tuesday, the Chiefs took control and scored six unanswered tallies to best the Cedar Rapids Kernels 6-2 at Dozer Park. Peoria starting hurler Darlin Saladin punched out a pair of Cedar Rapids batters to begin the game before the Kernels turned in
Chiefs Outslug Cubs to Take Series Finale
SOUTH BEND, IN – The Peoria Chiefs survived a wild seven-run seventh inning from the South Bend Cubs and held on for an 11–9 win on Sunday afternoon to take the series finale. With the win, Peoria improved to 2–7 on the season. Peoria carried a 9–1 lead into the
Chiefs Claim First Win, Split Doubleheader
SOUTH BEND, IN – After falling in game one of Saturday’s doubleheader by a final score of 4-2, the Chiefs earned their first win of the season by doubling up the South Bend Cubs 4-2 in the nightcap. With the win, Peoria snapped a seven-game slide to open the season.
Adkison Provides Power, Cubs Rally Past Chiefs
SOUTH BEND, IN – A Chase Adkison blast staked the Chiefs out to an early lead Friday, but the Cubs again rallied past Peoria in a 4-3 defeat at Four Winds Field. South Bend starter Nick Dean cruised through a 1-2-3 first inning. In the top of the second, the
Late Homer Lifts Cubs Past Chiefs
SOUTH BEND, IN – In a game that featured just six hits, Cristian Hernandez delivered a timely blast to propel the South Bend Cubs over the Peoria Chiefs 3-2 on Thursday. With the game tied at two in the bottom of the eighth inning, the Cubs jumped back on top
Chiefs-Cubs Postponed Wednesday
South Bend, IN – Wednesday’s tilt between the Peoria Chiefs and the South Bend Cubs was postponed due to rainy and snowy conditions. The game will be made up on Saturday, April 12 as part of a doubleheader. Game one will now start at 2:05 p.m EDT/1:05 p.m. CDT. Peoria’s
Big Inning Downs Chiefs Tuesday
South Bend, IN – The South Bend Cubs scored all five of their runs in the bottom of the sixth inning on Tuesday to rally past the Chiefs, 5-3. Peoria took a 2-0 lead into the home half of the sixth before a South Bend ambush quickly flipped the game