Every 2024 Rule 5 Draft pick, plus 1st-round analysis
DALLAS -- Arms were on the menu during Wednesday afternoon’s Rule 5 Draft at the Winter Meetings. A total of 15 players were taken in the Major League phase of this year’s Rule 5 and 11 of them were pitchers. It started when the White Sox took right-hander Shane Smith
DALLAS -- Arms were on the menu during Wednesday afternoon’s Rule 5 Draft at the Winter Meetings. A total of 15 players were taken in the Major League phase of this year’s Rule 5 and 11 of them were pitchers. It started when the White Sox took right-hander Shane Smith from the Brewers, and five of the first six selections all will try to make big league pitching staffs in the spring.
The Triple-A phase was particularly busy, with 68 total selections made. The 83 overall picks made were the most since the 2004 Rule 5 Draft.
Players who turned pro at age 18 or younger in 2020 or at age 19 or older in 2021 were eligible for selection in the Major League phase of the Rule 5 Draft if he wasn't on a 40-man roster. Clubs who took a player in that phase must pay his former team $100,000 and keep him on their active big league roster throughout the following season. The player can't be sent to the Minors without first clearing waivers and then getting offered back to his original organization for half his draft price.
It costs $24,000 to take a player in the Triple-A phase, with no restrictions about where those players can be placed in 2025.
Smith, a Wake Forest product who signed with the Brewers as an undrafted free agent in July of 2021, will pitch all of the 2025 season at age 25. Injuries slowed him early in his career, but he had 10 saves and a 1.96 ERA in 38 relief appearances, reaching Double-A in 2023. He totaled 94 1/3 innings last season, getting time as both a starter and reliever, finishing with a combined 3.05 ERA, a .204 batting average against and 10.8 K/9 rate across Double- and Triple-A. He can miss bats with his 93-94 mph fastball and he has a distinct curve and slider, getting good extension and generally being around the strike zone (2.8 BB/9 last year).
“When we talked about him before the protection deadline we knew he was a really good pitcher, a high-character pitcher we’ve liked going back to college,” Brewers special assistant to scouting Bryan Gale said. “Anyone that’s seen him when he’s been healthy in pro baseball [sees that] he’s been successful and he’s gotten better every year. When you have to make a tough decision like that, you know there’s some risk of losing a really good player. Everyone is happy Shane will get this opportunity, and we’re all pulling for him.”
Liam Hicks was the No. 2 pick, and the one position player taken among the top half dozen, nabbed by the Marlins from the Tigers, who didn’t have him very long. A 2021 ninth-rounder out of Arkansas State, Hicks is a catcher whom the Tigers just acquired from the Rangers at this past year’s Trade Deadline. He’ll get the opportunity to serve as the Marlins’ backup receiver behind Nick Fortes.
📩 SUBSCRIBE TO THE BASEBALL TRAVELER NEWSLETTER
Major League phase
Round 1
1. White Sox: Shane Smith, RHP (from Brewers)
2. Marlins: Liam Hicks, C (Tigers)
3. Angels: Garrett McDaniels, LHP (Dodgers, now LAA No. 29)
4. Athletics: Noah Murdock, RHP (Royals)
5. Nationals: Evan Reifert, RHP (Rays, now WSH No. 26)
6. Blue Jays: Angel Bastardo, RHP (Red Sox, now TOR No. 29)
7. Reds: Cooper Bowman, 2B (was ATH No. 20, now CIN No. 26)
8. Rays: Nathan Lavender, LHP (Mets)
9. Twins: Eiberson Castellano, RHP (Phillies, now MIN No. 13)
10. Cubs: Gage Workman, 3B/SS (was DET No. 29, now CHC No. 29)
11. Braves: Anderson Pilar, RHP (Marlins)
12. Padres: Juan Nuñez, RHP (was BAL No. 8, now SD No. 11)
13. Brewers: Connor Thomas, LHP (Cardinals, now MIL No. 30)
14. Phillies: Mike Vasil, RHP (was Mets No. 18, traded to TB)
Round 2
15. Braves: Christian Cairo, SS (Guardians)
The run on pitching really got going after Hicks, with the Angels taking lefty Garrett McDaniels from the Dodgers, the A’s nabbing right-hander Noah Murdock from the Royals, the Nationals selecting Evan Reifert from the Rays and right-hander Angel Bastardo going from the Red Sox to the Blue Jays. McDaniels spent most of the year in A-ball, but finished it in Double-A, posting a combined 3.19 ERA, a .229 BAA and 10.3 K/9 rate. Like Smith, he was a 2021 undrafted free agent who signed while rehabbing from Tommy John surgery.
“He’s a good arm and can spin two breaking balls,” Angels general manager Perry Minasian said about McDaniels. “He’s 94-95 mph with a good combination of strikeouts and ground balls. He was at a lower level but stuff is stuff, so we … felt like it was worth taking the shot. Left-handed relief is hard to get. There's a chance things work out and he makes the team, and he sticks, maybe starts down the road.”
Right-hander Juan Nuñez was the highest-ranked prospect taken in the Major League phase, with the Padres taking the Orioles’ No. 8 prospect. Another righty, Mike Vasil (Mets No. 18), was taken by the Phillies and traded to the Rays. Second baseman Cooper Bowman (A’s No. 20) and infielder Gage Workman (Tigers No. 29) were the other ranked prospects to change hands.
With the acquisition of Vasil, the Rays actually secured two Mets pitching prospects on Wednesday. The first was lefty Nathan Lavender, who appeared in just five games in 2024 due to an elbow injury that resulted in internal brace surgery. He’s slated to begin the year on the 60-day injured list.
“We’ve always liked him,” Rays assistant GM Kevin Ibach said. “I say this a lot when we execute trades, but we start history with a player coming out of the Draft, coming into professional baseball. With Nate, it was a left-handed arm that we liked a lot. Multiple pitches to get guys out, like the fastball, like the deception that he provides from the left-hand side.
“Obviously would like a healthy version of the player, but this was an opportunity to get someone that we can take over the throwing program, get him into Spring Training and develop under our hood until he’s ready to take the mound again.”
If Vasil sticks, it will be because he could potentially fill different roles. He’s largely started in his career, but don’t be surprised if the Rays employ him in different ways.
“The versatility he provides with that profile is probably what’s most appealing for him,” Ibach said. “There are a lot of different ways he can impact a 26-man roster, more so than just a traditional reliever.”
The Braves joined the Rays as the only team to acquire two players, taking righty Anderson Pillar from the Marlins and making the only Round 2 selection when they took infielder Christian Cairo from the Guardians. Other than the Mets, the Tigers were the only team to lose more than one player in the Major League phase, and both were position players in Hicks and Workman.
Minor League phase
Round 1
1. White Sox: Joseph Yabbour, RHP (Mets Single-A)
2. Rockies: Tyler Burch, RHP (Orioles Double-A)
3. Marlins: Ricky DeVito, RHP (Rangers Double-A)
4. Angels: Gustavo Rodriguez, RHP (A's Double-A)
5. Athletics: Henry Gomez, RHP (Cardinals Single-A)
6. Nationals: Hyun-il Choi, RHP (Dodgers Double-A)
7. Blue Jays: Richard Gallardo, RHP (Cubs Double-A)
8. Pirates: Franck De La Rosa, RHP (Athletics Double-A)
9. Reds: Joel Valdez, LHP (Yankees High-A)
10. Giants: CJ Widger, LHP (Padres Double-A)
11. Rays: Dan Hammer, RHP (Orioles Double-A)
12. Red Sox: Hobie Harris, RHP (Mets Double-A)
13. Twins: Trent Baker, RHP (Cardinals Double-A)
14. Cardinals: Oddanier Mosqueda, LHP (Yankees Double-A)
15. Cubs: William Jensen, RHP (Giants Double-A)
16. Mariners: Cesar Quintas, OF (Giants Double-A)
17. Royals: Bryan Gonzalez, OF (Red Sox Double-A)
18. Tigers: Junior Tilien, SS (Mets High-A)
19. Astros: Julio Rodriguez, RHP (Giants Double-A)
20. Mets: Michael Hobbs, RHP (Dodgers Double-A)
21. D-backs: Drake Osborn, C (Mets Double-A)
22. Braves: Blane Abeyta, RHP (Yankees High-A)
23. Guardians: Will Wilson, SS (Giants Double-A)
24. Padres: Eiker Huizi, RHP (Tigers High-A)
25. Brewers: Garrett Spain, OF (Blue Jays Double-A)
26. Yankees: Luis Durango, OF (Guardians Single-A)
27. Phillies: Eduardo Lopez, OF (Red Sox High-A)
28. Dodgers: John Rhodes, OF (Orioles Double-A)
Round 2
29. Rockies: Jose Torres, SS (Reds Double-A)
30. Marlins: Jack Winkler, SS (Athletics Double-A)
31. Angels: Josh Crouch, C (Tigers Double-A)
32. Blue Jays: Jacob Wetzel, OF (Cubs High-A)
33. Pirates: Aaron McKeithan, C (Cardinals Double-A)
34. Reds: Brandon Komar, RHP (Cardinals Double-A)
35. Giants: Sadrac Franco, RHP (Tigers Single-A)
36. Red Sox: Darvin Garcia, RHP (Pirates High-A)
37. Twins: Miguel Briceno, SS (Brewers Double-A)
38. Cardinals: Angel Gonzalez, RHP (Cubs High-A)
39. Cubs: Nolan Clenney, RHP (Mets Double-A)
40. Mariners: Taylor Floyd, RHP (Twins Double-A)
41. Royals: Landon Marceaux, RHP (Mets Single-A)
42. Astros: Jean Pinto, RHP (Orioles Double-A)
43. Braves: Samuel Mejia, RHP (Rays Single-A)
44. Padres: Jake Snider, OF (Rockies High-A)
45. Brewers: Zachary Peek, RHP (Orioles Double-A)
46. Phillies: Enmanuel Mejia, RHP (Rays Double-A)
Round 3
47. Orlando Ortiz-Mayr, RHP (Dodgers Double-A)
48. Pirates: Randy Labaut, LHP (Guardians Double-A)
49. Red Sox: Manuel Medina, LHP (Marlins Single-A)
50. Twins: Jefferson Valladares, C (Dodgers Complex League)
51. Cardinals: Jawilme Ramirez, RHP (Mets High-A)
52. Cubs: Robert Kwiatkowski, RHP (Red Sox Double-A)
53. Mariners: Adam Leverett, RHP (Rays Double-A)
54. Astros: Anderson Bido, RHP (Rockies Double-A)
55. Braves: Lizandro Espinoza, SS (Cardinals Single-A)
56. Padres: Andy Thomas, C (Giants Double-A)
57. Phillies: Agusto Calderon, RHP (Cardinals Single-A)
Round 4
58. Pirates: Steve Hajjar, LHP (Guardians Double-A)
59. Red Sox: Jack Anderson, RHP (Tigers Double-A)
60. Cardinals: Miguel Ugueto, OF (Red Sox High-A)
61. Mariners: Matt Cronin, LHP (Nationals Double-A)
62. Astros: Jack Blomgren, SS (Rockies High-A)
63. Braves: Dylan Shockley, C (Pirates Double-A)
64: Phillies: Elio Prado, OF (Orioles High-A)
Round 5
65: Pirates: Joel Mendez, OF (Yankees Complex League)
66. Astros: Nick Swiney, LHP (Giants Double-A)
67. Phillies: Gabriel Barbosa, RHP (Yankees Single-A)
Round 6
68. Phillies: Isaias Dipre, INF (Pirates DSL)
Jonathan Mayo is a reporter for MLBPipeline.com. Follow him on Facebook and @JonathanMayo, and listen to him on the weekly MLB Pipeline Podcast.
Nori Collects Two Extra-Base Hits, Three RBIs in Wednesday Win
WP: Zack Tukis (4-2, 7.62) LP: Greiber Mendez (6-4, 4.37) SV: Titan Kennedy-Hayes (7) BOX SCORE CLEARWATER, FL – Dante Nori homered and tripled to drive in three runs for the Clearwater Threshers (46-45, 10-15) in a 5-2 win over the Bradenton Marauders (42-49, 12-13) on Wednesday afternoon at BayCare
Ferrebus Comes off Bench to Win it for Threshers
WP: Danyony Pulido (1-0, 1.42) LP: Jose Garces (1-3, 4.30) BOX SCORE CLEARWATER, FL – Alirio Ferrebus entered Tuesday’s game between the Clearwater Threshers (45-45, 9-15) and the Bradenton Marauders (42-48, 12-12) in the fourth inning, finishing with two hits in a walkoff 3-2 win for the Threshers on Tuesday
Nori Smacks Two Hits Again, But Threshers Drop Third Straight
WP: Logan Berrier (3-1, 4.00) LP: Juan Amarante (0-2, 4.31) BOX SCORE LAKELAND, FL – The Clearwater Threshers (44-45, 8-15) managed six hits, all singles, in a 6-0 loss to the Lakeland Flying Tigers (56-30, 18-4) on Sunday afternoon at Publix Field at Joker Marchant Stadium. Clearwater looks to right
Threshers Grab Early Lead but Falter Late in Loss
WP: Ronny Chalas (2-0, 2.58) LP: Giussepe Velásquez (0-2, 4.26) SV: Duque Hebbert (2) BOX SCORE LAKELAND, FL – Despite a pair of hits and RBIs from Raider Tello, the Clearwater Threshers (44-44, 8-14) dropped their second-straight game to the Lakeland Flying Tigers (55-30, 17-4) in a 9-4 defeat on
Late Errors Sink Threshers
WP: Moises Rodriguez (3-1, 3.53) LP: Titan Kennedy-Hayes (1-3, 3.52) SV: Ignacio Briceño (2) BOX SCORE LAKELAND, FL – Alirio Ferrebus drove in three of four runs for the Clearwater Threshers (44-43, 8-13) as the Lakeland Flying Tigers (54-40, 16-4) charged ahead in the eighth inning to take down the
Saltiban, Nori Combine for Six Hits and Two Homers in Shutout
WP: Adilson Peralta (3-1, 3.98) LP: Michael Ross (2-4, 3.88) BOX SCORE CLEARWATER, FL – Devin Saltiban made a triumphant return to Clearwater with three hits and a home run as the Clearwater Threshers (44-42, 8-12) shut out the Fort Myers Mighty Mussels (36-49, 9-12) 7-0 in the series finale
Spikerman Goes Yard but Threshers Drop Second Straight
WP: Jason Doktorczyk (3-4, 4.83) LP: Sam Highfill (3-7, 4.89) BOX SCORE CLEARWATER, FL – John Spikerman continued his hitting streak with a sixth-inning home run, but the Clearwater Threshers (43-42, 7-12) fell 7-2 to the Fort Myers Mighty Mussels (36-48, 9-11) on Saturday night at BayCare Ballpark. Clearwater looks
Walton Scores Only Run as Threshers Snap Streak
WP: Christian Becerra (2-1, 2.63) LP: Eli Trop (0-2, 5.95) SV: Ruddy Gomez (5) BOX SCORE CLEARWATER, FL – TJayy Walton began the game with a massive triple, but the Clearwater Threshers (43-41, 7-11) couldn’t score after the first inning of a 4-1 loss to the Fort Myers Mighty Mussels
Nori’s Late Blast Seals Threshers Victory
WP: Luis Avila (2-0, 5.71, BS, 1) LP: Matt Gabbert (0-1, 2.25) SV: Danyony Pulido (1) BOX SCORE CLEARWATER, FL – Dante Nori extended the lead for the Clearwater Threshers (43-40, 7-10) with RBIs in the second and eighth innings of a 7-4 win over the Fort Myers Mighty Mussels
Clearwater Scores Final Three Runs in Comeback Win
WP: Adilson Peralta (2-1, 4.15) LP: Dylan Questad (3-6, 5.04) BOX SCORE CLEARWATER, FL – Despite dropping into an early 2-0 deficit, the Clearwater Threshers (42-40, 6-10) scored three unanswered runs to take down the Fort Myers Mighty Mussels (34-47, 7-10) 3-2 on Wednesday night at BayCare Ballpark. Clearwater will
Threshers Fail to Score Until Ninth Inning of Series-Opening Loss
WP: Adrian Bohorquez (2-3, 5.40) LP: Ryan Dromboski (6-5, 3.06) BOX SCORE CLEARWATER, FL – The Clearwater Threshers (41-40, 5-10) managed two hits and a late run in a 7-1 loss to the Fort Myers Mighty Mussels (34-46, 7-9) on Tuesday night at BayCare Ballpark. The Threshers look to turn
Spikerman Homers in Career Day as Threshers Complete Road Sweep
WP: Orlando Gonzalez (2-2, 3.27) LP: Brandon Decker (1-2, 3.10) BOX SCORE TAMPA, FL – The Clearwater Threshers (41-39, 5-9) amassed 14 runs on as many hits in a 14-9 victory over the Tampa Tarpons (43-36, 7-7) on Sunday afternoon at “The Tank” at George M. Steinbrenner Field. Clearwater will
Threshers Snap Skid, Take Two Games in Two Ballparks
WP: Luke Gabrysh (3-4, 4.24) LP: Mariano Salomon (0-1, 2.70) SV: Tristan Garnett (1) BOX SCORE CLEARWATER AND TAMPA, FL – In a doubleheader featuring a game that took place over three days in three different ballparks, the Clearwater Threshers (40-39, 5-9) took two wins over the Tampa Tarpons (43-35,
July Third Game Postponed For Second Straight Day
TAMPA, FL – Due to rain and inclement weather at George M. Steinbrenner Field, the continuation of Wednesday’s game between the Clearwater Threshers and Tampa Tarpons has been suspended for a second straight night. The game will be made up in a doubleheader on Saturday, July Fifth, with the first
Threshers Thursday Game Suspended in Fourth Inning
CLEARWATER, FL – Due to rain and lightning at BayCare Ballpark, Thursday’s game between the Clearwater Threshers and the Tampa Tarpons has been suspended in the middle of the fourth inning. The game will be resumed and completed in nine innings at a later date, with the Tarpons not scheduled
Villavicencio’s Grand Slam Not Enough as Threshers Drop Eighth Straight
WP: Cade Austin (4-1, 2.56) LP: Ryan Degges (3-1, 3.00) BOX SCORE CLEARWATER, FL – Juan Villavicencio hit an opposite-field grand slam in the eighth inning, but the Clearwater Threshers (38-39, 2-9) fell 13-7 on Wednesday night to the Tampa Tarpons at BayCare Ballpark. Clearwater returns home to try to
Threshers Start Series with Seventh Straight Loss
WP: Gage Ziehl (4-3, 3.55) LP: Ryan Dromboski (6-4, 3.09) BOX SCORE CLEARWATER, FL – The Clearwater Threshers (38-38, 2-8) failed to record an extra-base hit as they fell for the seventh-straight game in an 8-3 loss to the Tampa Tarpons (42-33, 6-4) on Tuesday night at BayCare Ballpark. Clearwater
Threshers Catcher Eduardo Tait Selected to NL Futures Game Roster
CLEARWATER, FL - For the third consecutive season, the MLB All-Star Futures Game will include a member of the Clearwater Threshers. Clearwater catcher Eduardo Tait will make his first Futures Game appearance as one of two 2025 Threshers to make the roster. Andrew Painter, who began his season in Clearwater,
Late Comeback Falls Short as Threshers Drop Third Straight
WP: Chris Williams Jr. (1-2, 4.85) LP: Erik Ritchie (2-1, 13.20) SV: Blair Calvo (2) BOX SCORE LAKELAND, FL – Despite scoring the opening run and spinning a shutout for most of the game, the Clearwater Threshers (38-34, 2-4) fell 3-2 to the Lakeland Flying Tigers (42-28) on Thursday afternoon
Tait Drives in Only Run in Threshers Loss
WP: Luke Stofel (5-0, 1.07) LP: Ryan Dromboski (6-3, 2.13) BOX SCORE LAKELAND, FL – The Clearwater Threshers (38-33, 2-3) scratched together four hits in a 7-1 loss to the Lakeland Flying Tigers (41-28, 3-2) on Wednesday evening at Publix Field at Joker Marchant Stadium. Clearwater looks for their first
Barbosa Fans Season-Best Five in Shutout Loss
WP: Zack Lee (3-3, 4.26) LP: Gabriel Barbosa (1-1, 3.83) SV: Ronny Chalas (5) BOX SCORE LAKELAND, FL – Despite 4.0 innings, one run, and five strikeouts from Gabriel Barbosa, the Clearwater Threshers (38-32, 2-2) were shut out by the Lakeland Flying Tigers (40-28, 2-2) on Tuesday night at Publix
Threshers Walk off Blue Jays in Tenth to Take Series
WP: Jose Peña Jr. (4-1, 0.71) LP: Silvano Hechavarria (0-1, 2.70) BOX SCORE CLEARWATER, FL – Kodey Shojinaga played the hero for the Clearwater Threshers (38-31, 2-1), walking off the Dunedin Blue Jays (35-33, 1-2) 4-3 to claim the series on Sunday afternoon at BayCare Ballpark. The Threshers go on
Nori Smacks Two Hits in Shutout Loss
WP: Bennett Flynn (2-3, 7.04) LP: Sam Highfill (3-5, 5.01) BOX SCORE CLEARWATER, FL – After a shutout on Friday night, the Clearwater Threshers (37-31, 1-1) experienced a 7-0 shutout at the hands of the Dunedin Blue Jays (35-32, 1-1) on Saturday night at BayCare Ballpark. Clearwater looks to finish
Stellar Pitching Shuts Out Blue Jays in Beach Dogs Win
WP: Ryan Degges (3-0, 2.02) LP: Johan Simon (1-2, 3.93) SV: Kevin Warunek (1) BOX SCORE CLEARWATER, FL – Ryan Degges spun the second-longest start of the season for the Clearwater Threshers (37-30, 1-0) as the pitching staff led the Beach Dogs to a 1-0 victory over the Dunedin Blue
Clearwater Finishes First Half with Late Surge in Loss
WP: Austin Cates (3-2, 3.91) LP: Ryan Dromboski (6-2, 2.01) BOX SCORE CLEARWATER, FL – Despite recording hits in all but two innings, the Clearwater Threshers (36-30) fell 7-2 to the Dunedin Blue Jays (34-31) to finish the first half on Thursday night at BayCare Ballpark. The Threshers look to