Check Swing Challenge system being tested in Arizona Fall League
It’s one of the great sports debates – was that a swing? Every baseball fan has participated in the discourse at one point or another. You’re watching a game when a pitcher throws, say, a nasty changeup that dives below the zone. Fooled only briefly, the hitter begins to swing
It’s one of the great sports debates – was that a swing?
Every baseball fan has participated in the discourse at one point or another. You’re watching a game when a pitcher throws, say, a nasty changeup that dives below the zone. Fooled only briefly, the hitter begins to swing but checks himself just in time. Or did he? The home-plate umpire can’t tell, calls a ball and the catcher points to the first-base or third-base umpire for appeal. Then fans see multiple camera angles and slow-motion video that the umpire doesn’t, and the debate rages.
Let’s face it, the check-swing call is one of the most subjective in baseball. Major League Baseball is now beginning preliminary testing of technology to gauge whether there is a way to create more clarity on check swings.
Using the same Hawk-Eye technology as the Automated Ball-Strike Challenge system already in place in the Arizona Fall League, the Check Swing Challenge is being used on a limited basis in a proof-of-concept stage at Salt River Field.
Teams will be able to challenge an on-field check-swing call to see if the swing crossed a 45-degree threshold from home plate.
That’s the elevator pitch. Here are more details on the latest review system coming to games at Salt River and why it’s being tested in the weeks ahead.
What is a check swing?
There is no definition for “check swing” in the Official Baseball Rules. The closest thing comes in the Definition of Terms where the first example of a strike is a pitch that “is struck at by the batter.” It’s up to the umpire to decide what “struck at” means. Rule 8.02(c) gets into how managers and catchers can ask for umpire help on “half swing” calls but does not expand from there.
Without official definitions, we’re left in a gray area. Common understanding is that the batter has to “cross the plane” or “break his wrists” in a check swing for it to be a strike, but that’s still at the umpire’s discretion without an official rule to fall back on.
So how would this change?
Under the Check Swing Challenge system, managers and catchers still ask for appeals, and umpires still make an initial call on the field. If players disagree, they can challenge the check-swing call to Hawk-Eye, bringing a replay to the in-stadium video board.
The check swing is called an official swing (and therefore a strike) if the review reveals that the bat exceeds a 45-degree threshold from home plate. Want an easier way to visualize that? The foul line is a 45-degree angle from home. If a right-handed batter swings beyond the first-base line, it’s a strike. If a left-handed batter swings beyond the third-base line, it’s a strike.
📩 CLICK HERE TO SUBSCRIBE TO BEN'S BIZ
How many challenges per team per game?
Each team gets to challenge two check-swing calls per game. If a team uses up those two challenges by the ninth inning, it is granted one additional challenge for the final frame.
Who can challenge?
This is the same as with an ABS Challenge. Only pitchers, hitters and catchers can ask for an official review.
Where will this be first tested?
The Check Swing Challenge will only be used in games played at Salt River Fields at Talking Stick in this year’s Arizona Fall League for now. Salt River serves as the Spring Training home of the D-backs and Rockies. This fall's Salt River Rafters roster is made up of players from those two systems as well as from the Nationals, Twins and Yankees.
Does the Arizona Fall League have a history of testing out potential new rules?
Yes! ABS, pitch clocks, bigger bases, mound visit limits, shift bans – many potential rule changes (both big and small) have been tested in the AFL before they’ve made (or, in some cases, not made) the Majors.
Sam Dykstra is a reporter for MiLB.com. Follow and interact with him on Twitter, @SamDykstraMiLB.
Eugene Emeralds Announce 2025 Coaching Staff
The Eugene Emeralds have announced their coaching staff for the 2025 season. Manager Jeremiah Knackstedt will lead the team for the 2nd straight season. Hitting coach Jared Walker & pitching coach Mario Rodriguez will also return to Eugene for their 2nd season. Drew Martinez will be joining the staff for
Unmissable Moments in Sports: Emeralds Style Revealed
Sports fans from all walks of life know that certain events transcend the game, offering moments of triumph, tradition, and excitement. For supporters of the Eugene Emeralds, we’ve curated a guide to the biggest and most prestigious sporting events worldwide. From motorsports to tennis and college athletics, each event showcases
Emeralds Home Clubhouse Manager Danny Okada named 2024 Home Clubhouse Manager of the Year
Minor League Baseball today announced the winners of the head groundskeeper of the year and home and visiting clubhouse managers of the year awards for each of the full season Minor League teams. The Emeralds home clubhouse manager Danny Okada has been named as the Northwest League home clubhouse manager
Joe Holstedt: A life of service
Joe Holstedt was a little nervous for this interview. He’s the most gregarious, loud, overtly friendly person in the Emeralds’ orbit. But the very nature of his job forces him into the background, where he operates far more comfortably. Watching the game — the man only called upon by injury.
Emeralds Announce Specialty Nine Jersey Honoring the Negro Leagues and Eugene’s Black Community
The Eugene Emeralds are excited to announce a new speciality jersey that honors the Negro League and Eugene’s Black Community. The Emeralds put together a focus group with Black community leaders to create something that represented them. The NAACP of Eugene-Springfield, the Black Cultural Initiative and former Emeralds player George
Emeralds Visiting Clubhouse Manager Takes Home Clubhouse Attendant Award
Minor League Baseball has announced the 2023 groundskeeper and clubhouse attendant awards. Travis Wong, the Emeralds visiting clubhouse attendant, has been given the award in the Northwest league. The winners were selected using the results of league managers, players and executives throughout the 2023 season. “We are extremely proud of
Emeralds Win Golden Bobblehead Award For Best Promotion
The Eugene Emeralds were announced as the winners of the Golden Bobblehead award for the best promotion or event after honoring their local history with the Exploding Whales identity. It was announced the Emeralds won the award at the MiLB Fall meetings that are taking place in Las Vegas. Allan
Emeralds Baseball Submits Funding Options for New Facility to MLB, Seeks Additional Time for Completion
EUGENE, OREGON - October 2nd, 2023 - In accordance with the Major League Baseball (MLB) September 30th deadline, the Eugene Emeralds announce the submission of all current funding options for their proposed new multi-use facility. With approximately two-thirds of the estimated $90.4 million funding identified, the team is cautiously optimistic
In honor of National Hat Day, here are 10 of MiLB's most popular caps of '24
We are celebrating the small yet mighty canvas that is the Minor League cap for National Hat Day. Clubs across the Minors utilize them as a fun way to represent their teams, regions and sometimes even their parent organizations. Not to mention they also look pretty sweet. Here's a close
Here are 10 of the top Minor League jerseys in 2024
Fans typically buy a sports jersey because of who's wearing it. But in the Minor Leagues, what’s on a jersey can often mean so much more. Teams have a way of making fans part of franchises by bringing local culture into their jersey and theme nights. “It's taking pride in
Eldridge among Giants prospects on AFL stage
SCOTTSDALE, Ariz. -- Bryce Eldridge has plenty of ingredients to become a frontline starter. He's a 6-foot-7 left-hander with a 92-94 mph fastball that reaches 96 and a low-80s slider that misses bats, and he dominated as a reliever while helping Team USA win the 2022 World Cup at the
Minor League Player Spotlight: Giants' Eldridge
Bryce Eldridge feels like he always plays up to the competition. It could explain how his numbers have improved with every new level of the Minors he has reached since being drafted by San Francisco No. 16 overall in the 2023 Draft. He even has his chance to show it
Top Minor League moments from 2023
In 2023, Minor League Baseball featured thrilling prospect debuts, electric performances and moments that went beyond the box score. All commemorated by the inaugural MiLB Awards on MLB Network. Let's look back on the year in MiLB.
The Road to The Show™: Giants’ Whisenhunt
Each week, MiLB.com profiles an elite prospect by chronicling the steps he's taken toward achieving his Major League dream. Here's a look at third-ranked Giants prospect Carson Whisenhunt. For more stories about players on The Road to The Show, click here. There’s been a lot working against Carson Whisenhunt over
MiLB honors top promotions of '23
This is an excerpt from the latest edition of the Ben's Biz Beat Newsletter, bringing Minor League Baseball business and culture news to your inbox each and every Thursday. Check out the full newsletter HERE. Subscribe HERE.
MiLB honors Golden Bobblehead Award winners
LAS VEGAS -- Minor League Baseball announced the winners of the 2023 Golden Bobblehead Awards for top promotional activities and events in six categories.
Ben's Biz eats: Best of the Pacific Northwest
This is an excerpt from the latest edition of the Ben's Biz Beat Newsletter, bringing Minor League Baseball business and culture news to your inbox each and every Thursday. Check out the full newsletter HERE. Subscribe HERE.
Some of the Minors' most popular jerseys
Jerseys can be gateways. And in the Minor Leagues, there’s plenty to explore. The kit can represent the town, a favorite food, the local culture, an important issue. And with longer affiliation partnerships, more teams have used them to connect with their parent clubs. Not to mention, they’re nice to
Hops Take Series Finale Against Eugene
The Eugene Emeralds dropped the series finale against the Hops by a final score of 7-1. With the loss today the Emeralds take a series split this week in Hillsboro. The Ems record now sits at 61-59 on the season and 27-27 in the 2nd half. The Hops jumped out
The best of the Giants' Minor League ballparks
The Minor League Ballpark Guides series presented by Wyndham brings all the most fun features of Minors ballparks across America (and one in Canada!) onto your desktop, tablet or mobile device, whether you're interested in taking a virtual tour from where you sit or planning a trip to catch some
MiLB clubs embrace communities on Juneteenth
Over the past week, Negro League Baseball has had a welcome presence on the Minor League landscape. Teams have taken on alternate identities, worn Negro League-inspired jerseys and welcomed special guests to the stadium in honor of Juneteenth. Declared an official holiday in 2021, Juneteenth celebrates the end of slavery
Emeralds make themselves at home on the road
As the University of Oregon baseball season was winding down, the High-A Eugene staff couldn't help but scoreboard watch. While the Ducks' success didn't directly impact the Emeralds’ standings, there’d be a ripple effect, as the two clubs share PK Park in Eugene, Ore. “It kind of just became more
Copa de la Diversión en la comunidad
Copa de la Diversión is a multi-faceted fan engagement platform focused on embracing the cultures and values that resonate most with local Latino/a communities. Indeed, some of the greatest success stories within Copa -- sponsored by Nationwide, the platform's official insurance partner -- relate to each club’s ability to make
Minor Leagues bring the love on Mother's Day
Where would we be without our moms? While people everywhere celebrated Mother's Day, teams and players around the Minors made their affection known with pink uniforms, moms honored before the game and even home runs hit in maternal honor. Because moms always support their kids win or lose, it made