19 All-Star Game Selections: Josh Bell (1x), Gerrit Cole (6x), Elias Diaz (1x), Tyler Glasnow (1x), Clay Holmes (2x), Brock Holt (1x), Mitch Keller (1x), Jeff Locke (1x), Starling Marte (2x), Austin Meadows (1x), Paul Skenes (2x)
5 Gold Glove Awards: Starling Marte (LF - 2x - 2015, 2016 - PIT), Jacob Stallings (C - 2021 - PIT), Ke'Bryan Hayes (3B - 2x - 2023 - PIT, 2025 - PIT/CIN)
2 CY Young Award Winners: Gerrit Cole (2023 - NYY), Paul Skenes (2025 - PIT)
1 Silver Slugger Award Winner: Josh Bell (DH - 2022 - WSH/SD)
1 Rookie of the Year Winner: Paul Skenes (2024 - PIT)
3 World Series Championships: Brock Holt (2018 - BOS), Hunter Strickland (2014 - SF, WSH - 2019)
1 All-Star Game MVP: Elias Diaz (2023 - COL)
Josh Bell...1B...2014
Cody Bolton...RHP...2019
Nick Burdi...RHP...2018
Bubba Chandler...RHP...2022
Tsung-Che Cheng...INF...2022
Gerrit Cole...RHP...2012
Oneil Cruz...INF/OF...2019
Elias Diaz...C...2013
*Must have appeared in one game for an MLB team in 2025 or 2026
Adam Frazier...INF...2014
Tyler Glasnow...RHP...2014
Thomas Harrington...RHP...2023
Ke'Bryan Hayes...INF...2017
Clay Holmes...RHP...2015
Connor Joe...INF...2016
Jared Jones...RHP...2021
Osvaldo Bido...RHP...2019
J.T. Brubaker...RHP...2016
Hunter Barco...LHP...2023
Mitch Keller...RHP...2016-18
Pablo Reyes...INF...2016
Starling Marte...OF...2010
Reese McGuire...C...2015
Nick Mears...RHP...2019
Kevin Newman...INF...2016
Luis Ortiz...RHP...2021
Luis Peralta...LHP...2022, 2023
Endy Rodriguez...C...2021
Blake Sabol...C/OF...2021
Paul Skenes...RHP...2023
Jacob Stallings...C...2013-14
Jose Soriano...RHP...2021
Hunter Stratton...RHP...2019
Hunter Strickland...RHP...2010, 2012
Justin Topa...RHP...2016
Trevor Williams...RHP...2016
Konnor Griffin...INF...2025
Nathan Adcock...RHP...2017-18
Dario Agrazal...RHP...2017-18
Tanner Anderson...RHP...2016
Jayson Aquino...RHP...2015
Yhonathan Barrios...RHP...2014
Vic Black...RHP...2011
Jeremy Bleich...LHP...2015
John Bormann...C...2017-19
Steven Brault...LHP...2015
Jake Brentz...LHP...2017-18
Ramon Cabrera...C...2011
Shane Carle...RHP...2014
Rodolfo Castro...INF...2019
Blake Cederlind...RHP...2018-19
Will Craig...INF...2017
Brandon Cumpton...RHP...2011, 2017
Chase D'Arnaud...INF...2011, 2013
Alex Dickerson...OF...2012
Montana DuRapau...RHP...2015
Luis Escobar...RHP...2018-19
Eric Fryer...C...2010
Willy Garcia...OF...2013
Taylor Gushue...C...2016
Alen Hanson...INF...2013
Taylor Hearn...LHP...2017
Brock Holt...INF/OF...2010
Phil Irwin...RHP...2011-12
JaCoby Jones...INF...2015
Nick Kingham...RHP...2013, 2016-17
Kevin Kramer...INF...2016
Max Kranick...RHP...2019
Jeff Locke...LHP...2010
Jordan Luplow...OF...2016
Drew Maggi...INF...2011-12
James Marvel...RHP...2017-18
Wyatt Mathisen...INF...2015-16
Kyle McPherson...RHP...2010-11
Alex McRae...RHP...2016
Austin Meadows...OF...2015
Cal Mitchell...OF...2019
Diego Moreno...RHP...2010-11
Max Moroff...INF...2014
A.J. Morris...RHP...2014
Bryan Morris...RHP...2010
Dovydas Neverauskas...RHP...2015
Gift Ngoepe...INF...2010, 2012-13
Jared Oliva...2018...OF
Jose Osuna...INF...2013-14
Hunter Owen...INF...2018
Gregory Polanco...OF...2013
Casey Sadler...RHP...2012
Adrian Sampson...RHP...2013
Tony Sanchez...C...2010
Edgar Santana...RHP...2016
Bo Schultz...RHP...2018
Josh D. Smith...LHP...2014
Robert Stock...RHP...2015
Travis Swaggerty...OF...2019
Stephen Tarpley...LHP...2016
Cam Vieaux...LHP...2017-18
Brandon Waddell...LHP...2016
Duke Welker...RHP...2010-11
Daniel Zamora...LHP...2017