Phils' Painter takes big step in TJ recovery, K's 2 in Fall League
SCOTTSDALE, Ariz. -- Sound the alarm, Andrew Painter is back on the hill. As Philadelphia’s top-ranked pitching prospect took a deep breath and threw his warmup tosses ahead of his first game action since March 2023, an ambulance siren blared outside of Scottsdale Stadium -- a moment of levity amid
SCOTTSDALE, Ariz. -- Sound the alarm, Andrew Painter is back on the hill.
As Philadelphia’s top-ranked pitching prospect took a deep breath and threw his warmup tosses ahead of his first game action since March 2023, an ambulance siren blared outside of Scottsdale Stadium -- a moment of levity amid an arduous path back to the mound.
Painter’s first step in his return from July 2023 Tommy John surgery came Saturday afternoon during Arizona Fall League play, as he took the mound with “Phillies” emblazoned across his chest. The right-hander pumped his fastball as hard as 99-100 mph during his first inning of action, which included getting rehabbing Mets infielder/outfielder Jeff McNeil to fly out and Giants top-ranked prospect Bryce Eldridge to strike out on a breaking ball.
The second inning proved more laborious for Painter: He allowed a leadoff solo homer to Tigers No. 9 prospect Josue Briceño, going on to yield an RBI later in the frame as well. In total, MLB’s No. 32 prospect threw 29 pitches (18 for strikes) and allowed two runs on three hits and one walk with a pair of strikeouts.
“I thought obviously the results weren't exactly what I wanted, but arm's healthy and that was the biggest takeaway,” Painter said. “Everything felt like it was coming out good, like my old self.”
Painter’s old self was one of the most dominant Minor League pitching prospects to come from the high school ranks in the past decade. In 109 2/3 frames across four levels, Painter struck out 167, posted a 1.48 ERA and saw batters produce a combined .507 OPS. His 70-grade heater was so dominant at the lower levels that he climbed as high as Double-A Reading as a 19-year-old.
To start 2023, Painter was MLB Pipeline’s No.1-ranked pitching prospect in all of baseball (No. 6 overall). But after just two innings of a Grapefruit League outing on March 1, 2023, he was shut down. He attempted to rehab his elbow with non-surgical measures, but by the summer, he knew it was the necessary course of action in the long term.
“More of a new chapter,” Painter said of his altered mindset. “It's a new elbow, so I'm a new person now. You can look at that stuff and think back, but I think it's just a dangerous spot to be in.”
Still just 21 years old, Painter’s gone through the gamut not just physically by having the game taken away, but mentally as well. He lauded the work done at the club’s complex alongside Dr. Traci Statler, the Phillies’ mental performance scouting and rehab coordinator.
“Baseball's been my thing growing up and it's been something I've loved,” Painter said. “Getting that taken away from me, I think it just made me appreciate the game so much more. I just really look forward to any time I get to be out here on the field and just go to the field every day.”
Painter is expected to throw around 20 innings over the coming weeks for the Glendale Desert Dogs, priming him for a chance to compete for a big league rotation spot come 2025. Despite not having consistently pitched since late 2022, when he has tossed just 28 1/3 innings at the Double-A level, the 6-foot-7 hurler is firmly on the Phillies’ radar.
“I do think he’ll be pitching at the big league level at some point in ‘25,” Phillies president of baseball operations Dave Dombrowski said earlier this week. “He’s not going to be able to go out there like a big league starter and pitch every five or six days and pitch a whole season and have 180 innings. He’s going to be limited, much more than that.
📩 CLICK HERE TO SUBSCRIBE TO BEN'S BIZ
“So how do we do that? Do we start pitching him in games later? Do we start pitching him at the Minor Leagues once a week and limit the innings? Could he pitch here? Yes, but it also depends how he does.”
“I think it was always a possibility,” Painter said of pitching in the Fall League, “but I know some of the main focus was the rehab process. It's a long process. So I think that the thought process there was kind of just be where your feet are at and live in the present and not put those goals in front until that time comes.
“End goal is always pitching in the big leagues, and pitching in the big leagues for a while.”
Jesse Borek is a reporter/coordinator of prospect content at MLB Pipeline and MiLB. Follow him on Twitter @JesseABorek.
Reading and Binghamton Rained Out Tuesday Night
(Binghamton, NY) - Tuesday night's game between the Reading Fightin Phils and Binghamton Rumble Ponies has been postponed due to rain. The game will be made up as a part of a doubleheader on Saturday, with the first game beginning at 12 p.m. Both games will be seven innings. Wednesday
Fightin Phils Partnering with Berks County Agriculture for Cup Giveaway on June 18
(Reading, PA) - The Reading Fightin Phils, Double-A affiliate of the Philadelphia Phillies, are excited to partner with Berks County Agriculture, who will sponsor the America's Classic Ballpark Commemorative Cup for the first 2,000 adults, on Wednesday, June 18, against the Hartford Yard Goats. First pitch for the game is
Felix Reyes Walk Off Homer Give Fightin Phils Extra Inning Win
BOX SCORE (Reading, PA) - The Reading Fightin Phils (7-18) took the final game of the series against the Harrisburg Senators (13-14) 4-3 in a walk off win. The Reading Fightin Phils took the early lead in the bottom of the first with a lead-off home run from Robert Moore.
Harrisburg Downs Reading in Rain Shortened Game
BOX SCORE (Reading, PA) - The Reading Fightin Phils (6-18) fell to the Harrisburg Senators (13-13) 9-1 in a six-inning rain-shortened game. Harrisburg came out strong in the top of the first inning. Phillip Glasser got things started with a single on a ground ball to right field. Yohandy Morales
Fightin Phils Ninth Inning Rally Falls Short in Loss to Harrisburg
BOX SCORE (Reading, PA) - The Reading Fightin Phils (6-17) fell to the Harrisburg Senators (12-13) 6-4 in the fourth game of the series. The Harrisburg Senators took the early lead in the top of the first. Nick Schnell doubled on a sharp fly ball to center field and then
Fightins Snap Skid with One Run Win over Harrisburg
BOX SCORE (Reading, PA) - Home runs from Robert Moore and Leandro Pineda led the Reading Fightin Phils (6-16) to a 5-4 win over the Harrisburg Senators (11-13) on Thursday night, snapping Reading's 10-game losing streak. Reading struck first early on thanks to a solo home run from Leandro Pineda
Chace Strong on Mound as Reading Drops Game Two to Harrisburg
BOX SCORE (Reading, PA) - The Reading Fightin Phils (5-16) fell to the Harrisburg Senators (11-12) 6-3 in the second game of the series. The Fightin Phils got themselves on the board first in the bottom of the fourth inning. Aidan Miller and Hendry Mendez both singled during their time
Late Reading Rallies Come up Short in Game One Defeat to Harrisburg
BOX SCORE (Reading, PA) - The Reading Fightin Phils (5-15) fell to the Harrisburg Senators (10-12) 9-7 in the opening game of the series. After two hitless innings for both teams, the Harrisburg Senators were the first on the board thanks to a solo home run from Daylen Lile in
Fightin Phils Take on the Harrisburg Senators in Upcoming Home Series
(Reading, PA) - The Reading Fightin Phils, Double-A affiliate of the Philadelphia Phillies, are back in town to take on the Harrisburg Senators, Double-A affiliate of the Washington Nationals. The series kicks off on Tuesday, April 29 at 6:45 p.m. at FirstEnergy Stadium. Tuesday, April 29 through Thursday, May 1
Reading and Portland Rained Out for Second Straight Game Sunday
(Portland, ME) - Sunday's game between the Reading Fightin Phils and Portland Sea Dogs has been postponed due to rain. Saturday and Sunday's rained out games will be made up as part of doubleheaders on Wednesday, May 21 at 5 p.m. and Friday, May 23 at 4 p.m., when the
Reading and Portland Rained Out Saturday
(Portland, ME) - Saturday's game between the Reading Fightin Phils and Portland Sea Dogs has been postponed due to rain. The game will be made up at a date to be determined when Reading visits Portland from May 20-25. Sunday's game will remain as a schedule single game at 1
Gabe Mosser Shines as Fightins are Walked Off by Sea Dogs
BOX SCORE (Portland, ME) - A walk-off home run from Tyler Miller in the bottom of the ninth led the Portland Sea Dogs (11-6) to a 2-1 win over the Reading Fightin Phils (5-14) on Friday night from Delta Dental Park. With the win, Portland clinches this week's series as
Chuck King's Career Best Outing Not Enough as Fightins Fall
BOX SCORE (Portland, ME) - Five-shutout innings from Chuck King was not enough as the Reading Fightin Phils (5-13) fell 4-3 to the Portland Sea Dogs (10-6) on Thursday night from Delta Dental Park. With the loss, Reading has dropped the first three games to Portland this week and have
Fausnaught Fires Five Strong Frames as Fightins Fall
BOX SCORE (Portland, ME) - Five-strong innings from Braeden Fausnaught wasn't enough as the Reading Fightin Phils (5-12) fell 5-1 to the Portland Sea Dogs (9-6) on Wednesday night from Hadlock Field. With the win, the Sea Dogs jumped out to a 2-0 edge in this week's six-game series. After
Late Portland Push Downs Reading in Game One
BOX SCORE (Portland, ME) - The Reading Fightin Phils (5-11) fell to the Portland Sea Dogs (8-6) 9-8 in the first game of the series. Reading took the early lead in the top of the first when Aidan Miller singled on a sharp ground ball to left field and then
Miller Has Two Knocks as Reading Falls in Finale to Binghamton
BOX SCORE (Reading, PA) - The Reading Fightin Phils (5-10) fell to the Binghamton Rumble Ponies (7-6) 3-2 in the final game as Binghamton took the series 4-2. The Rumble Ponies struck first with a lead off solo home run from Jeff McNeil which put Binghamton up 1-0. They extended
Fightin Phils Drop Third Straight to Binghamton
(Reading, PA) - The Reading Fightin Phils (5-9) dropped their third straight game to the Binghamton Rumble Ponies (6-6) 6-1 in the fifth game of the series. The Rumble Ponies struck first in the top of the first inning. Both Jeff McNeil and Francisco Alvarez singled which was then followed
Late Rally Not Enough as Fightin Phils Drop Second Straight
BOX SCORE (Reading, PA) - The Reading Fightin Phils (5-8) fell to the Binghamton Rumble Ponies (5-6) 6-5 in the fourth game of the series. Binghamton got on the board first in the top of the third inning. Jett Willams walked after his time at bat. Francisco Alvarez made it
Fightin Phils Drop First Game of Series to Rumble Ponies
BOX SCORE (Reading, PA) - The Reading Fightin Phils (5-7) fell to the Binghamton Rumble Ponies (4-6) 6-2 in the third game of the series. The Rumble Ponies got themselves on the board first with a lead off home run from Jett Williams, making it 1-0. Reading was able to
Miller Knocks Three Hits as Fightin Phils Down Rumble Ponies
BOX SCORE (Reading, PA) - The Reading Fightin Phils (5-6) defeated the Binghamton Rumble Ponies (3-6) 7-4 in the second game of the series. The Rumble Ponies got off with a similar start as the previous game. Nick Morabito doubled on a ground ball to left field which was then
Fightins Home Run Barrages Downs Rumble Ponies in Series Opener
BOX SCORE (Reading, PA) - The Reading Fightin Phils (4-6) took the series opener against the Binghamton Rumble Ponies (3-6) 12-2. Binghamton took the early lead in the top of the first inning. Nick Morabito walked after his time up at bat and was followed by Ryan Clifford who doubled
Top Prospects Clash as Rumble Ponies Come to Town
(Reading, PA) - The Reading Fightin Phils (3-6), Double-A affiliate of the Philadelphia Phillies, are back in FirstEnergy Stadium to take on the Binghamton Rumble Ponies (3-4), Double-A affiliate of the New York Mets. The first game is on Tuesday, April 15 at 6:45 p.m. and kicks off the six-game
Fightins Rally Late Again to Split Series with Somerset
BOX SCORE (Bridgewater, NJ) - The Reading Fightin Phils (3-6) came back and beat the Somerset Patriots (4-5) 8-7 in the last game of the series on Sunday. The Fightin Phils split the series with the Patriots 3-3. Reading got on the board first early in the game when Keaton
McGarry Strong Again as Fightins are Swept in Doubleheader
BOX SCORE 1 BOX SCORE 2 (Bridgewater, NJ) - Despite another strong outing from Griff McGarry, the Reading Fightin Phils (2-6) dropped both ends of Saturday's doubleheader to the Somerset Patriots (4-4). The Patriots won game one 10-5 and were victorious in the second game 4-1. Game One The Fightin
Fightin Phils and Patriots Postponed on Friday Night
(Bridgewater, NJ) - Friday night's game between the Reading Fightin Phils and Somerset Patriots has been postponed due to inclement weather. The game will be made up as a doubleheader on Saturday beginning at 4 p.m. Both games will be seven innings and there will be an approximate 30-minute break