Seigler switches things up as catcher, outfielder
Switch-hitter? Sure. Switch-pitcher? Rare, but not unprecedented. But switch-fielder? Meet Anthony Seigler, who appeared Wednesday night for Double-A Somerset as a left-handed-throwing left fielder and Thursday night as a right-handed-throwing catcher. Seigler’s ambidextrous nature first gained notoriety when the Yankees selected him 23rd overall in the 2018 Draft out of
Switch-hitter? Sure. Switch-pitcher? Rare, but not unprecedented. But switch-fielder? Meet Anthony Seigler, who appeared Wednesday night for Double-A Somerset as a left-handed-throwing left fielder and Thursday night as a right-handed-throwing catcher.
Seigler’s ambidextrous nature first gained notoriety when the Yankees selected him 23rd overall in the 2018 Draft out of Cartersville (Ga.) HS. While scouts marveled at his ability to throw in the mid-80s and equally effectively with either arm, he was ultimately drafted as a catcher due to his all-around ability.
Since joining the pro game, Seigler has spent nearly every defensive play of his career behind the dish -- and throwing with his right hand. But he made his first career appearance in left field Wednesday for the Yankees’ Double-A affiliate donning his glove covering up his right hand. And as the axiom goes, the ball will find you.
“When I was younger, I always played outfield lefty, so there was no doubt that if I ever got the opportunity to do it in pro ball, it was definitely going to be lefty,” Seigler said.
Seigler first made a foray into the outfield -- right field, specifically -- in 2021 during a stint with High-A Hudson Valley. Two defensive outs were recorded, neither of which were by him. But when Guardians prospect Juan Brito lifted a fly ball to left in the bottom of the seventh Wednesday, it found Seigler’s glove -- and in the process, confused even the broadcaster, who mistakenly first referred to him as fellow left-handed-fielding teammate Elijah Dunham, and then eventually as, “somebody.”
With his first outfield putout pocketed and a 1.000 fielding percentage as a left fielder, Seigler returned to his catching duties Thursday. From the get-go, Double-A Akron put his right-handed-throwing abilities to the test, as after the leadoff batter drew a walk, he bolted for second during the next plate appearance. With an on-the-mark throw, Seigler recorded his ninth caught stealing of the year and 50th of his pro journey.
Which begets the question: Could Seigler be the uber-rare left-handed-throwing catcher?
The last catcher to serve as a southpaw during big league action was Benny Distefano, who did so for three games with the Pirates in 1989.
“I never really got the opportunity, nor thought about, catching lefty,” Seigler said. “I’ve had that in the back of my mind, and people have always brought it up to me or asked me if I ever did it, but I just feel a lot more comfortable righty.”
Major League Baseball’s history with players throwing with both arms has largely been focused upon those who did so while on the mound: Tony Mullane, Larry Corcoran, Ice Box Chamberlain, Greg A. Harris and Pat Venditte, among them. Jurrangelo Cijntje wowed evaluators at the 2022 MLB Draft Combine when he ripped off 94-96 mph heaters as a righty and 88-92 as a southpaw. The Brewers selected him in the 18th round of the 2022 Draft, but he chose to play collegiately at Mississippi State, where he has continued as an ambidextrous pitcher.
Pinpointing the act of Major or Minor Leaguers throwing with both arms from the field has been both murky and notoriously difficult. While it’s not a well-trodden path, it’s not a currently barren one. Whereas three's company, Mets 2018 third-round Draft selection Carlos Cortes plays the outfield left-handed and the infield right-handed, which although he has primarily focused on his outfield work since 2019, gives switch-throwing position players at least two to call their own across the Minors.
“It’s cool to think about playing the outfield, especially as a left-hander, but I feel like my main position is catcher,” Seigler said.
“But if the opportunity ever presents itself again, I will always be ready.”
Jesse Borek is a reporter/coordinator of prospect content at MLB Pipeline and MiLB. Follow him on Twitter @JesseABorek.
Reno's Rally in the Ninth Sends Comets to 8-7 Loss
Reno Aces — 8 Oklahoma City Comets — 7 Friday, June 6, 2025 – Chickasaw Bricktown Ballpark – Oklahoma City, Okla. Game Summary: The Reno Aces hit two home runs to score three runs in the ninth inning as they came back to defeat the Oklahoma City Comets, 8-7, Friday
Senzel Homers as Comets Secure First Win of Series
Oklahoma City Comets — 5 Reno Aces — 3 Thursday, June 5, 2025 – Chickasaw Bricktown Ballpark – Oklahoma City, Okla. Game Summary: Nick Senzel homered in the third inning and the Oklahoma City Comets led the rest of the way in a 5-3 win against the Reno Aces Thursday
Comets Fold Against Aces, 6-5
Reno Aces — 6 Oklahoma City Comets — 5 Wednesday, June 4, 2025 – Chickasaw Bricktown Ballpark – Oklahoma City, Okla. Game Summary: Trey Mancini hit a three-run home run for the Reno Aces in the ninth inning as the Aces came back to defeat the Oklahoma City Comets, 6-5,
Aces Take Series Opener Versus Comets Tuesday
Reno Aces — 7 Oklahoma City Comets — 6 Tuesday, June 3, 2025 – Chickasaw Bricktown Ballpark – Oklahoma City, Okla. Game Summary: The Oklahoma City Comets fought back to tie Tuesday night’s game in the eighth inning, but the Reno Aces scored a go-ahead run in the ninth inning
Special Theme Nights Highlight Weekend of Comets Home Series That Starts Tonight at Chickasaw Bricktown Ballpark
OKLAHOMA CITY – The Oklahoma City Comets will host their first Salute to Armed Forces Night of the season along with Heroes and Villains Night as part of a six-game home series that starts at 7:05 tonight against the Reno Aces to kick off the month of June at Chickasaw
Okey Leads Way as Comets Secure Key Series Win Sunday
Oklahoma City Comets — 12 Las Vegas Aviators — 3 Sunday, June 1, 2025 – Las Vegas Ballpark – Las Vegas, Nev. Game Summary: Chris Okey racked up four RBI on four hits to lead the way as the Oklahoma City Comets won a key series finale against the Las
Comets Topple Aviators in Saturday Slugfest
Oklahoma City Comets — 17 Las Vegas Aviators — 11 Saturday, May 31, 2025 – Las Vegas Ballpark – Las Vegas, Nev. Game Summary: The Oklahoma City Comets set season highs with 17 runs and 20 hits, emerging victorious over the Las Vegas Aviators, 17-11, in a Saturday night slugfest
Comets Fight Back, but Aviators Walk Off with Win
Las Vegas Aviators — 9 Oklahoma City Comets — 7 Friday, May 30, 2025 – Las Vegas Ballpark – Las Vegas, Nev. Game Summary: Colby Thomas hit a two-run, walk-off home run in the bottom of the ninth inning, sending the Las Vegas Aviators to a 9-7 win over the
Ward Goes Deep Three Times as Comets Win
Oklahoma City Comets — 9 Las Vegas Aviators — 3 Thursday, May 29, 2025 – Las Vegas Ballpark – Las Vegas, Nev. Game Summary: Ryan Ward went 5-for-5 with three home runs and six RBI, headlining the Oklahoma City Comets’ 9-3 win over the Las Vegas Aviators Thursday night at
Aviators Start Hot and Beat Comets, 8-2
Las Vegas Aviators — 8 Oklahoma City Comets — 2 Wednesday, May 28, 2025 – Las Vegas Ballpark – Las Vegas, Nev. Game Summary: The Las Vegas Aviators scored three runs in the bottom of the first inning and led for the rest of the game during an 8-2 win
Comets Hit Five Homers, Rally to Win in Las Vegas
Oklahoma City Comets — 11 Las Vegas Aviators — 9 (10 innings) Tuesday, May 27, 2025 – Las Vegas Ballpark – Las Vegas, Nev. Game Summary: The Oklahoma City Comets overcame a late four-run deficit and hit three home runs over the final three innings to beat the Las Vegas
Big Fifth Inning Helps Send Comets to 9-6 Win Sunday
Oklahoma City Comets — 9 Sacramento River Cats — 6 Sunday, May 25, 2025 – Chickasaw Bricktown Ballpark – Oklahoma City, Okla. Game Summary: The Oklahoma City Comets scored seven runs in the fifth inning and the bullpen held the Sacramento River Cats scoreless over the final five innings in
Sacramento Sends Comets to Saturday Loss
Sacramento River Cats — 11 Oklahoma City Comets — 4 Saturday, May 24, 2025 – Chickasaw Bricktown Ballpark – Oklahoma City, Okla. Game Summary: The Sacramento River Cats scored runs in five of the final six innings of Saturday night’s game to defeat the Oklahoma City Comets, 11-4, at Chickasaw
Comets Fall to River Cats, 8-6, Friday
Sacramento River Cats — 8 Oklahoma City Comets — 6 Friday, May 23, 2025 – Chickasaw Bricktown Ballpark – Oklahoma City, Okla. Game Summary: The Oklahoma City Comets chipped away at the early lead built by the Sacramento River Cats Friday night, but would go on to an 8-6 loss
Comets Close Out Win with Seven Unanswered Runs Thursday
Oklahoma City Comets — 9 Sacramento River Cats — 5 Thursday, May 22, 2025 – Chickasaw Bricktown Ballpark – Oklahoma City, Okla. Game Summary: The Oklahoma City Comets closed out Thursday night’s game by scoring seven unanswered runs to come back and defeat the Sacramento River Cats, 9-5, at Chickasaw
Tickets On Sale Now For MLB's Home Run Derby X in OKC Aug. 23
OKLAHOMA CITY – Tickets are on sale now for the 2025 Home Run Derby X tour, including its Aug. 23 stop in Oklahoma City at Chickasaw Bricktown Ballpark. Home Run Derby X is an exciting three-on-three co-ed competition built around power hitting and athletic catches showcasing a home run derby
OKC Unable to Overcome Early Deficit in 8-1 Loss
Sacramento River Cats — 8 Oklahoma City Comets — 1 Wednesday, May 21, 2025 – Chickasaw Bricktown Ballpark – Oklahoma City, Okla. Game Summary: For the second straight game, the Sacramento River Cats built an early lead through three innings that provided enough offense to defeat the Oklahoma City Comets
River Cats Ride Early Lead to Defeat OKC in Series Opener
Sacramento River Cats — 11 Oklahoma City Comets — 5 Tuesday, May 20, 2025 – Chickasaw Bricktown Ballpark – Oklahoma City, Okla. Game Summary: The Sacramento River Cats jumped out to an 8-0 lead and went on to defeat the Oklahoma City Comets, 11-5, Tuesday night in the series opener
Comets Host Bark in the Park Tonight Presented by Tito's Handmade Vodka
OKLAHOMA CITY – The Oklahoma City Comets feature Bark in the Park tonight at Chickasaw Bricktown Ballpark for the first of six straight home games through Sunday against the Sacramento River Cats. Gates open at 6 p.m. and first pitch is slated for 7:05 tonight with Bark in the Park
Express' Two-Out Rallies Send Comets to Sunday Loss
Round Rock Express — 5 Oklahoma City Comets — 4 (10 innings) Sunday, May 18, 2025 – Dell Diamond – Round Rock, Texas Game Summary: The Round Rock Express scored three runs with two outs in the ninth inning and two runs with two outs in the 10th inning to
Another Six-Run Strike Leads to Victory
Oklahoma City Comets — 7 Round Rock Express — 3 Saturday, May 17, 2025 – Dell Diamond – Round Rock, Texas Game Summary: The Oklahoma City Comets once again used a six-run inning to lead the way to victory during a 7-3 win over the Round Rock Express Saturday night
Senzel's Slam Highlights 8-2 Win
Oklahoma City Comets — 8 Round Rock Express — 2 Friday, May 16, 2025 – Dell Diamond – Round Rock, Texas Game Summary: The Oklahoma City Comets scored six runs in the top of the third inning highlighted by a grand slam from Nick Senzel, leading to an 8-2 win
Comets Come Back, but Fall in Extras
Round Rock Express — 6 Oklahoma City Comets — 5 (10 Innings) Thursday, May 15, 2025 – Dell Diamond – Round Rock, Texas Game Summary: The Round Rock Express scored twice in the bottom of the 10th inning to beat the Oklahoma City Comets, 6-5, Thursday night at Dell Diamond.
Houser, Express Blank Comets
Round Rock Express — 5 Oklahoma City Comets — 0 Wednesday, May 14, 2025 – Dell Diamond – Round Rock, Texas Game Summary: Adrian Houser threw 8.2 scoreless innings and kept the Oklahoma City Comets without a hit until the seventh inning as the Round Rock Express blanked the Comets,
Big Third Inning Helps Lift Comets to Win
Oklahoma City Comets — 8 Round Rock Express — 5 Tuesday, May 13, 2025 – Dell Diamond – Round Rock, Texas Game Summary: After falling behind by three runs early, the Oklahoma City Comets scored six runs in the third inning and went on to defeat the Round Rock Express,